PDA

View Full Version : Giants fan here


Giantsfan
09-25-2006, 06:13 PM
Greetings Steelers fans, I come in peace. We got smashed by the Seahawks so feel free to bash me. The reason I am here is to get you guy's opionion on our DC Tim Lewis. I am constantly tired of seeing our defense shut teams down on 1st and 2nd down, only to give up a 1st on 3rd and long with NOBODY around the other teams players. This guy just doesn't seem to get it as far a defending the pass. Our DB's are contantly giving 8-12 yd cushions and we are getting killed. What was Lewis like with you guys? Why was he fired?

Stlrs4Life
09-25-2006, 06:16 PM
Hey Giants Fan. Probably for similar reasons that you state, and believe that he didn't get along with Cowher, and at the time, we needed change there.

Ambridge
09-25-2006, 06:44 PM
I never liked Tim Lewis's defense..........it seemed like it was more read and react than playing agressive and attack.

Cape Cod Steel Head
09-25-2006, 07:37 PM
I think you answered your own question. Third and long.

newjacksm
09-25-2006, 08:28 PM
I actually Signed up to make this same exact post.. I would like more steeler fans to give more explaination please :)

thanks!

X-Terminator
09-25-2006, 08:47 PM
Joey Porter complained many times about Tim Lewis' defense, that it wasn't aggressive enough. His scheme is a read-and-react scheme, and as a result, we were horrible on third and long ourselves. I remember the Atlanta game here back in 2002, when the Steelers were up by 17 late in the game and the Falcons came back to tie it up - they were consistently getting beat on third and long, including a 3rd and 22 and a 3rd and 24. Bottom line, his scheme sucks and I'm not surprised at all at the Giants' D not being able to stop anyone on third down. Your personnel on D isn't built for that - it's built to attack, similar to the Eagles' D - you have Strahan and Umenyiora, for God's sake. Lewis needs to turn them loose!

Atlanta Dan
09-25-2006, 09:02 PM
Tim Lewis came in as Steelers' defensive coordinator after Jim Haslett went off on his doomed journey to coach the Saints

This link to a story on Lewis getting fired after the 2003 season provides a nice summary of what did Lewis in - a woefully slow secondary

http://www.phillyburbs.com/pb-dyn/news/103-01072004-222516.html

The downfall of Lewis' defense began in late 2001 when the Bengals, with nothing to lose, threw on every down for around 400+ yards and won in OT. By 2002, the word was out Dwayne Washington and Chad Scott could not cover anyone one on one and teams (starting with the Pats and Raiders to open the 2002 season) went to spread offenses/no huddle/ throwing on every down and Lewis' defenses never recoverd..

Lewis tried to compensate by going away from the zone blitz to cover 2, which reduced sacks and took the Steelers away from the attacking zone blitz style that had come in with Cowher in 1992.

While Lewis was too conservative a defensive coach for Cowher's taste, Cowher holding onto his assistants the last several years has been a definite change - Cowher had a well-earned rep of being a pain to work with (Dick LeBeau and special teams wizard Bobby April made lateral moves to get out in the mid-1990s). In addition, starting with the 1993 season, Cowher had a rep of making ritual human sacrifices of assistant coaches when he had a bad season.

So, as for why he got fired, Lewis had too conservtive a coaching style and Cowher needed to blame someone for a losing season in 2003 (caused in large part by the Steelers wrecked O-line and going pass happy, which was something Tim Lewis could not be blamed for).

Assuming Coughlin lasts until 2007, do not be surprised if Lewis is tossed from the sled by Coughlin to save his own skin.

Livinginthe past
09-25-2006, 09:31 PM
I can probably sum it up in 3 words.

No Pass Rush.

It doesn't matter how good your DB's are or how much cushion they give if your D-line isnt pressuring the QB.

NM

ThunderJacobs
09-25-2006, 09:41 PM
I'd like to add to my fellow Giants fan. Maybe I wasn't paying attention but our D was bad yesterday that I don't remember getting to 3rd down very much, it's not only the 3rd down D. Oh and I'd like to disagree with X-terminator. Even though sometimes he does dumb thing and drops Strahan in coverage TL hasn't really hindered Strahan and Osi that much in fact he usually rushes 4 and Giants fans hate it. Our DEs are just not playing well.

SteelShooter
09-25-2006, 10:09 PM
Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome Welcome ........................................and did I say "Hey There!" :bringit:

steelcurtain09
09-25-2006, 10:48 PM
this place is a mixture of all types of fans
3 giants fans at the same time
wow!

jaysta
09-25-2006, 10:51 PM
Welcome into the best fan site on the planet! :helmet: :tt02:

Prosdo
09-25-2006, 10:52 PM
Hey GiantsFan. Welcome to SF! Enjoy your stay!

floodcitygirl
09-25-2006, 11:38 PM
Welcome Giantsfan! Hope you enjoy SF!!! :smile: