PDA

View Full Version : Ben suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder???


I-Want-Troy's-Hair
10-01-2006, 12:42 AM
Will be interesting to see what Ben that steps out on the field next Sunday. I pretty much agree with everyone else this isn't the same Ben we saw last year.

Heavy load?

By Scott Brown
TRIBUNE-REVIEW
Sunday, October 1, 2006

Something appears not to be right with Ben Roethlisberger.

It shows in the passer rating that through two games is roughly a third of what it was in 2005. It shows in dubious decisions such as when he tried to force a pass to tight end Heath Miller in the end zone last Sunday in a 28-20 loss to the Bengals.

And it may even show in the way he laughed off a question about what the cumulative effects of two traumatic incidents have had on him and, by extension, his play.

"The doctor said nothing's wrong with my brain," Roethlisberger said, "and it seems like I'm having brain farts out there."

Yet, there may be forces at work that not even Roethlisberger can comprehend, forces that have led or at least contributed to the two subpar showings he has recorded in consecutive Steelers losses.

One psychiatry expert said Roethlisberger may be suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which can lead to feelings of anxiety and being overwhelmed.

Another said the adrenaline that has always worked for Roethlisberger may now be working against him due to biological changes over which Roethlisberger has no control.

One thing that can not be disputed is Roethlisberger has been through a lot since becoming the youngest quarterback ever to win the Super Bowl.

A little more than three months after celebrating his 24th birthday in March, Roethlisberger lost his aura of invincibility and nearly his life in a motorcycle accident. His injuries included multiple facial fractures and required seven hours of surgery at Mercy Hospital.

He reported to training camp in July on time, but less than a week before the Steelers' season opener, Roethlisberger had an emergency appendectomy.

"You start adding up his trauma, somewhere you've got to figure his stress level is increased," said Dr. Ron Knause, a sports medicine psychiatrist who is based in the Tampa Bay area. "Without a doubt."

Knause has worked with professional athletes for years, specifically on working through off-the-field issues in order to maximize their performance on the field.

Knause, who once traveled with the USFL's Tampa Bay Bandits for this very purpose, said Roethlisberger may have PTSD. That, he added, could be affecting him on the field, especially since his position demands that he make split-second decisions on a regular basis.

Through his first two games, Roethlisberger has thrown five interceptions and no touchdowns and completed just under 50 percent of his passes.

His passer rating is 34.3, which is 64.3 points less than it was in 2005 when Roethlisberger finished third in the NFL in the category.

"He may have anxiety that would impair his ability to perform at peak performance levels that he was able to do previously," Knause said.

Dr. Kevin Guskiewicz, who served as a graduate assistant athletic trainer with the Steelers in the late 1980s and early 1990s, believes Roethlisberger is in good hands with the team's medical personnel.

"In my opinion, he's getting the best care he could be getting anywhere in the country," said Guskiewicz, who is the director of the sports medicine research laboratory at the University of North Carolina. "I'm sure if there were any lingering (effects), they would be picking up on them."

Steelers doctors could not be reached for comment on this story.

Len Genduso, a psychotherapist at Columbia Presbyterian Hospital in New York City, said it is hard for anyone to fathom what Roethlisberger has been through, Roethlisberger included.

How his brain has processed what has happened to him is something that could be hindering Roethlisberger on the field, Genduso said. Given the trauma he experienced in the span of about four months, Roethlisberger could have undergone a significant biochemical change and not even know it, Genduso said.

He said that the excitement of anticipation and the terror associated with trauma are on the same emotional continuum.

What Roethlisberger has been through may have led to some re-wiring in his brain, Genduso said, and the adrenaline he now gets before games subconsciously tells him that his body is in danger of imminent trauma.

"He may be having a lot of effects even if he's not having flashbacks," Genduso said.

Knause said the motorcycle accident and appendectomy left Roethlisberger with physical, mental and emotional damage.

"I'll bet 10 to 1 nobody ever looked at his emotional component," Knause said.

A major reason for that, he said, is the culture of football.

Players are programmed to be tough, and Roethlisberger has long sported the prototypical rugged look with his sturdy build and ample facial hair.

Sometimes that toughness masks denial, Knause said, pointing to the recent case of Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Chris Simms.

Simms took a beating last Sunday, yet he kept playing even though he later had to be rushed to a hospital and have his spleen removed.

Knause said Roethlisberger could be in denial over some emotional issues from the motorcycle accident and appendectomy.

"All his training is 'I'm fine,' " Genduso said. "He could have PTSD and not be fully aware that he's suffering the effects of it."

That could be revealed in various forms of talk, behavioral and cognitive therapy.

That he is even playing is "incredible," said Dr. John Corrigan, a rehabilitation psychologist and the founder of the Ohio Valley Center for Brain Injury.

"I think it's been documented what he's been through," Steelers coach Bill Cowher said "but, again, he's a very resilient young man."

Roethlisberger is also a confident one. At least on the surface.

Three days after the loss to the Bengals, Roethlisberger said the 1-2 Steelers would be a different team coming off the bye week. But he stopped just short of saying he is back to where he was physically and mentally before the motorcycle accident.

"I'm working out, and I really feel good about where I'm at," Roethlisberger said. "Coach wants me to put on a little more weight, but I feel good with where I'm at right now."

SteelBreeze
10-01-2006, 11:50 AM
I don't think its as much a matter of PTSD as it is just a temporary loss of self confidence. This happens to even the most gifted athletes spanning every sport. Ben doesn't need counseling, he needs to recover physically, practice with a healthy first team offence, and play one good game. A good performance next sunday coupled by a win and Big Ben will be just fine.

I am more worried about our receiver tandem at this point. Seems they can get open. A couple of nice catches from slightly off target throws would help Ben get his confidence level to last years high real fast.

tony hipchest
10-01-2006, 11:53 AM
insightful article. there may be alot of truth to it. weve all seen him rebound pretty easilly from football related injuries. it makes sense a motorcycle would be a whole other can of worms.

stillers4me
10-01-2006, 11:55 AM
We can speculate till we're blue in tha face. Only time will tell. Too bad we have to brood about for two whole weeks.........

I just know a Bungles loss today will do soooooo much for my downer mood.

Atlanta Dan
10-01-2006, 11:56 AM
Ben played like this the last 6 weeks of the 2005 season and in the SB - PTSD is a clever hypothesis but I think he just needs to get healthy WRs and keep the DBs honest by tucking the ball and running for positive yardage a few times.

Another lousy game next week and these stories will multiply.

BIGBENFASTWILLIE
10-01-2006, 02:33 PM
Ben played like this the last 6 weeks of the 2005 season and in the SB - PTSD is a clever hypothesis but I think he just needs to get healthy WRs and keep the DBs honest by tucking the ball and running for positive yardage a few times.

Another lousy game next week and these stories will multiply.

I disagree......Ben played great in the playoffs.....Lousy in the superbowl......But had some good games in the playoffs.......

klick81
10-01-2006, 02:43 PM
I've been hinting to this for a while now...it would not surprise me if it is true. He is human.

BigJen
10-01-2006, 04:15 PM
PTSD????:bs: I think PMS is more like it:sofunny: . Honestly he is not suffering from trauma, it's actually drama!:cheer:

HometownGal
10-01-2006, 04:28 PM
PTSD????:bs: I think PMS is more like it:sofunny: . Honestly he is not suffering from trauma, it's actually drama!:cheer:

You must be suffering from a sugar deficiency - why don't you go and choke on....errrr....I mean stuff those jowls full of Twinkies? :tt02:

Have you ever been through what Ben's been through? Until you can answer in the affirmative, STFU. :troll:

steelergirlrocks
10-01-2006, 05:34 PM
Well, whatever Ben may be going through, we love him and the rest of the team too!

Go Steelers!!

stunta86
10-01-2006, 05:55 PM
well if he doesn't snap out of it soon we are gonna have maddox part 2

24seven
10-01-2006, 06:01 PM
what do you mean Maddox part 2?? it would be Kordell part 3.....or Bubby part 8.......

Atlanta Dan
10-01-2006, 06:11 PM
5 fumbles in 2 weeks - maybe Carson Palmer has PTSD?

Hines0wnz
10-01-2006, 06:33 PM
I think it is more along the lines of a sophomore jinx. He played well in his rookie season and last year but not in the Super Bowl. Maybe the ol' jinx caught him a bit later than expected? I know he has been through much trauma this summer but maybe he is thinking too much and his brain is overwhelmed.

This bye week will do him some good.....too bad the Chargers lost today, now they will be taking their frustration out on him. Should be a good test of whether he is back yet or not.

theropodx
10-02-2006, 03:31 AM
lol omg you people are cracking me up. ptsd. omg!

this is why fans don't make good coaches.

theropodx
10-02-2006, 03:34 AM
I think it is more along the lines of a sophomore jinx.

That's it! A Jinx!!! lol this has got to be the dumbest thread yet. is this really what happens when we have 2 bad games? Man, what if we'd lost them by more than one score, one turnover. Get a grip dudes! :dang:

Hines0wnz
10-02-2006, 10:07 AM
That's it! A Jinx!!! lol this has got to be the dumbest thread yet. is this really what happens when we have 2 bad games? Man, what if we'd lost them by more than one score, one turnover. Get a grip dudes! :dang:


It is better than thinking it is PTSD since he isnt playing like the Big Ben we have been spoiled by since he began starting. Yeah he has had trauma but I'm not buying into the whole psychology of it or....I could just post about nothing and crack myself up? :wink02:

HometownGal
10-02-2006, 10:32 AM
It is better than thinking it is PTSD since he isnt playing like the Big Ben we have been spoiled by since he began starting. Yeah he has had trauma but I'm not buying into the whole psychology of it or....I could just post about nothing and crack myself up? :wink02:

I'm not ruling out that Ben could possibly be suffering from a little PTSD. I went through a somewhat similar surgery almost 5 years ago, though for different reasons. The physical trauma heals a lot faster than the emotional trauma after an accident/illness, as well as such a detailed and delicate surgery. It took almost 6 months for my inner healing to catch up with the outer healing. My self-confidence and self-esteem were almost non-existent and it took time to rebuild those very vital characteristics. I was a bit impatient with myself in wanting to get back to a "normal" life and it only set me back, so I sucked it up, re-learned the art of patience and worked very hard to get "balanced" again. In Ben's case, he is coming off of a great season where he became the youngest QB to win a SB trophy. Four months later, comes the motorcycle accident which almost took his young life and two months after that, he is stricken with appendicitis and yet another surgery and another setback. This young man has been through a helluva lot in a short period of time - if it didn't affect him mentally/emotionally, I wouldn't think he was even human. PTSD is a condition that you yourself have to work through. A lot of support from family and friends helps tremendously and Ben definitely has that support network in place. Admittedly, I was quite shocked that Ben played at all before the bye week. Yes, he was cleared by his doctors medically, but no medical expert can look inside of your head to see how you are going to be affected emotionally/mentally. I have no doubt that Ben will get where he needs to be, as he is a very driven young man. I am hoping this week off gave him the time he needs to find his balance and rediscover his self-confidence. :smile:

Hines0wnz
10-02-2006, 11:12 AM
I am hoping this week off gave him the time he needs to find his balance and rediscover his self-confidence. :smile:

We are all hoping for that! :tt02: