PDA

View Full Version : Big Ben practices, likely to start against Raiders


MACH1
10-25-2006, 02:50 PM
Looks like he's going to start.
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2638373

mopartodd
10-25-2006, 02:53 PM
I hope he's okay and not rushing back. As someone who has experienced 3 concussions........

What was I saying....Ooh look at the birds!

JK

klick81
10-25-2006, 03:36 PM
Wow. I hope he will be okay. Our O-line better step it up.

SteelerFanInCA
10-25-2006, 03:43 PM
Hopefully our O line can step it up a notch. We need to protect Big Ben.

Cape Cod Steel Head
10-25-2006, 04:32 PM
I think its a foolish decision to play him.

RoethlisBURGHer
10-25-2006, 04:35 PM
If he's actually okay and medicaly cleared to play,I see no reason why he shouldn't start.

However,if he shows any ill-effects,he should be removed immediatly.

Atlanta Dan
10-25-2006, 04:54 PM
Hopefully our O line can step it up a notch. We need to protect Big Ben.


I agree but Dr. Z. from SI.com makes these observations while ranking the Steelers #20 this week:

This is what I saw on the first drive against Atlanta. I saw Grady Jackson literally throw center Jeff Hartings clear and dump Willie Parker for a five-yard loss. I saw Josh Mallard, a reserve, a street free agent, beat Alan Faneca to the spot and sack Ben Roethlisberger. Now those are two All-Pros I saw getting beaten by a 33-year-old fatso and a youngster who'd been out of football for three years. I mean what's going on, anyway? The offensive line is an area of the team that's always been inviolate. Or is it now just in violet?

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2006/writers/dr_z/10/25/rankings.part2/index.html

Maybe (hopefully) this is all a smokescreen by Cowher, if this afternoon's P-G is accurate:

Quarterback Ben Roethliberger pulled on his pads, uniform -- and helmet -- and reported to practice this afternoon. However, he did very little during the two-hour workout.

"I feel good," Roethlisberger said before taking the practice field with his teammates. "Just trying to get ready to get out there and help the team any way I can."

Coach Bill Cowher listed Roethlisberger as questionable after a concussion knocked him out of last Sunday's game in Atlanta in the third quarter. Tests conducted on Roethlisberger's head and neck showed no damage and as long as he continues to pass the mental tests he will be given the rest of the week, he could play Sunday.

Big D
10-25-2006, 04:55 PM
i would hate to see ben go out like troy aikman and steve young. And hell even merril hoge for that matter

DoctorJanSteelerFan
10-25-2006, 05:00 PM
I hope he's okay and not rushing back. As someone who has experienced 3 concussions........
What was I saying....Ooh look at the birds! JK
:sofunny:

My posts are becoming a broken record: :blah: It would be INSANE, medically negligent and potentially life-threatening if they allow Ben to play this week. Sure, maybe nothing will happen but is it worth jeopardizing his entire career for a few games? In other words, let's say Ben played this week against Oakland, was sacked, hit his head on the ground. The chances are much greater now not just that he would have a concussion but also that he could sustain permanent brain injury and never play football again. So, let?s hope and pray NFL-affiliated and NON-NFL-affiliated neurologists will think of him as their own son or brother and not a money-making ?Star-QB? machine.

Maybe this is a smokescreen to keep our opponents guessing and not insanity on the part of doctors and coaches especially considering Ben was only doing a "light" workout?

If not?? Then let the Steeler Nation rise and say:
SAVE BEN. PLAY BATCH.:banging: :dang: :tt02:

Big D
10-25-2006, 05:08 PM
:sofunny:

My posts are becoming a broken record: :blah: It would be INSANE, medically negligent and potentially life-threatening if they allow Ben to play this week. Sure, maybe nothing will happen but is it worth jeopardizing his entire career for a few games? In other words, let's say Ben played this week against Oakland, was sacked, hit his head on the ground. The chances are much greater now not just that he would have a concussion but also that he could sustain permanent brain injury and never play football again. So, let?s hope and pray NFL-affiliated and NON-NFL-affiliated neurologists will think of him as their own son or brother and not a money-making ?Star-QB? machine.

Maybe this is a smokescreen to keep our opponents guessing and not insanity on the part of doctors and coaches especially considering Ben was only doing a "light" workout?

If not?? Then let the Steeler Nation rise and say:
SAVE BEN. PLAY BATCH.:banging: :dang: :tt02:
thank you for your perspective about all this. I was wondering if you could explain to us in detail the medical risk of ben playing.

sumo
10-25-2006, 05:28 PM
Even though the Raiders are a bad team as a whole -- it's almost all on their offense - their defense is actually pretty good and they are decent at bringing pressure too ..I would hate to see Ben get hit several times and then have to sit out several games from the cumulative effect of back-to-back concussions -- he is far more likely to have another one since he had one just last week and it doesn't have to be a helmet-to-helmet hit either -- Steve Young, Chris Miller and Joe Montana got concussions later in their careers from being thrown to the turf and glancing minimal hits ...that's what it will come to eventually if he's not careful -- I also agree with Dr Jan based on my own experience coaching at the lower levels --- Play Charlie!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cape Cod Steel Head
10-25-2006, 05:37 PM
I could undrstand having him play if it was against a quality opponent. But the Raiders ! Come on! If we can't beat the Raiders with Batch then we might as well roll over and die! Why risk Ben being hit, and hurt AGAIN by big fat Warren Sapp?How would that look?

Atlanta Dan
10-25-2006, 06:01 PM
I could undrstand having him play if it was against a quality opponent. But the Raiders ! Come on! If we can't beat the Raiders with Batch then we might as well roll over and die! Why risk Ben being hit, and hurt AGAIN by big fat Warren Sapp?How would that look?

You raise an interesting point I have been pondering regarding the expressed concerns for Ben's health by playing this week against this team.

Would we be as concerned about the risk to Ben's health if it were a better opponent in more important game (say Ben was coming off a concussion going into a playoff game?) In other words, whether he gets plastered by Warren Sapp this week or (hypothetically) by Shawn Merriman in the AFC Championship should the time of his next concussion make any difference?

That is what cost/benefit analysis is all about but I find myself wondering whether the risks to Ben playing are being regarded by at least myself as more intolerable because the Steelers are having a lousy year with no currently viable prospects to make the playoffs and, even so, should be able to beat Oakland whether Ben plays or not.

Any thoughts?

Stillers43
10-25-2006, 07:51 PM
It is too risky to start our fanchise QB against the lowly Raiders. Nice post! SAVE BEN PLAY BATCH! Kinda catchy.

19ward86
10-25-2006, 08:00 PM
i think they should start batch and if we dig ourselves a whole then we put ben in either in the late second quarter or the early part of the third quarter.

stillers4me
10-25-2006, 08:30 PM
i think they should start batch and if we dig ourselves a whole then we put ben in either in the late second quarter or the early part of the third quarter.

Me thinks the hole has already been dug.........

Duck44
10-25-2006, 08:33 PM
I think its a foolish decision to play him.

I agree. This guy could be a Steeler QB for the next 10-12 years. Why risk permanent injury for onr game when Batch has looked good.

DoctorJanSteelerFan
10-25-2006, 11:47 PM
..I would hate to see Ben get hit several times and then have to sit out several games from the cumulative effect of back-to-back concussions -- he is far more likely to have another one since he had one just last week and it doesn't have to be a helmet-to-helmet hit either -- Steve Young, Chris Miller and Joe Montana got concussions later in their careers from being thrown to the turf and glancing minimal hits ...that's what it will come to eventually if he's not careful -- I also agree with Dr Jan based on my own experience coaching at the lower levels --- Play Charlie!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bravo, Coach Sumo! :tt02:

DoctorJanSteelerFan
10-26-2006, 12:11 AM
thank you for your perspective about all this. I was wondering if you could explain to us in detail the medical risk of ben playing.
I'll give it a shot, Big D...:cheers:... I'm in a rush so I hope I make sense...:blah:

“Concussions often cause significant and sustained neuropsychological impairments in information-processing speed, problem solving, planning, and memory, and these impairments are worse with multiple concussions. Suffering a second concussion while still having symptoms from a previous concussion can be lethal.”
http://www.neurosurgery.pitt.edu/trauma/concussion.html
In addition, symptoms sometimes don't show up until after a time-delay of days, weeks or even months.

“Head trauma is a common problem in sports that has the potential for serious complications if not managed correctly. Even what appears to be a "minor ding" or "bell ringer" without loss of consciousness, has the risk of catastrophic results in a [player] who is returned to action too soon. The medical literature and lay press are reporting instances of death from "second impact syndrome" even after mild concussions.”
http://www.uil.utexas.edu/athletics/health/concussions.html

http://www.exra.org/Concussion%20risk-2003.htm
A Two-Year Prospective Study of Relative Risk of a Second Cerebral Concussion, concluded that the "risk of sustaining a cerebral concussion is nearly six times greater for individuals with a history of previous concussion than for individuals with no such history."

Multiple concussions suffered over a period of months or years increases the risk of permanent brain damage and post-concussion syndrome, in which neurological or cognitive problems become chronic. Even mild concussions occurring within hours, days or weeks of each other can result in "Second Impact Syndrome," (SIS) which can be fatal. Second Impact Syndrome (SIS) results from an acute, usually fatal brain swelling that occurs when a second concussion is sustained before complete recovery from a previous concussion.

Each concussion is cumulative and can have long-term effects. If there is loss of consciousness (LOC) WITH the concussion, then even more precautions must be taken. Some of the effects do not show up right away. There also must be a proper amount of time to recover from each separate incident. Following a concussion without full recovery, even a minor "bump" to the head can result in another concussion. Allowing an athlete to return to play too early increases their chances of more serious brain injury. Memory, reaction time and processing speed among others can all be affected. (IMO, it is one of the reasons Ben looked so sluggish until Kansas City. Also adding insult to injury, IMO he returned prematurely following his appendectomy, contributing to unconscious "guarding" of his abdomen when an opponent tried to sack him.)

The NCAA Concussion Study (reported in JAMA 2003;290:2549-2555) concluded that there ARE cumulative effects for concussions. "...Players with a history of previous concussions are more likely to have future concussive injuries than those with no history; 1 in 15 players with a concussion may have additional concussions in the same playing season; and previous concussions may be associated with slower recovery of neurological function."

According to news reports on MSNBC (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15418846/from/RS.3/), Ben lost consciousness, had some amnesia with the play and still has headaches. All of these symptoms indicate a severe concussion and a concussion that involves ANY loss of consciousness is labeled severe and classified as a Grade 3 Concussion.. Loss of consciousness, headaches and memory loss are more often associated with severe concussions. There is no such thing as a "minor concussion." In most cases a single concussion should not cause permanent damage. A second concussion soon after the first one, however, does not have to be very strong for its effects to be deadly or permanently disabling.

First, let’s set aside Ben’s first “Motorcycle Concussion” with its additional trauma. The “Atlanta Concussion” WITH his Loss of Consciousness (LOC) of several minutes puts him at risk for the “Second Impact Syndrome” (SIS-as described above) until he is fully recovered. Research has shown that allowing enough time for the brain to heal and recover before return-to-play is crucial in preventing more severe damage from possible further brain trauma during contact play. So an additional hit to his head (even a minor one and there is no way of calculating what force would be required) before his brain has had a chance to "recover" could result in not only another concussion but also varying neurological deficits and injury as noted above. Now, let's add back in the first “Motorcycle Concussion” (even though 4 months ago) PLUS the “Atlanta Concussion” and go back over his highschool and college career for any mild concussions, and this puts him at ADDITIONAL major risk for "SIS" and "Numerous Concussive Syndrome".

Both the American Academy of Neurology and Colorado Medical Society (used by the NCAA) describe a “Grade 3 Concussion” as a concussion with loss of consciousness of ANY duration. It is the most severe concussion. (These “published” guidelines have not been updated for almost 10 years and we now recognize that concussions are even MORE serious than thought.)

Guidelines for a FIRST Grade 3 Concussion include:
----Brief Loss of Consciousness (seconds)-----1 week minimum until return to play
----Prolonged LOC (minutes)--------------------2 weeks minimum
For MULTIPLE Grade 3 Concussions (according to AAN):
----AAN: 1 month or longer based on clinical decision of attending physician
----Colorado Medical Society guidelines: Terminate season.

SAVE BEN. PLAY BATCH.

holmes
10-26-2006, 12:42 AM
If Ben does play it will be a total incompetence on the coaching staff as well as the medical staff. The only thing that matters in the NFL (not for long - which may amount to the amount of time we have Ben, unless someone stops him from foolishly making a wrong decision to come back to soon) is winning...at any costs. We need to protect our investment, even if we do have a few more losses. But we probably won't with the way Charlie is playing.