View Full Version : Ed Bouchette's Daily Question: Sit Key Players?

12-02-2006, 06:48 AM
Ed Bouchette's Daily Question
Saturday, December 02, 2006

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Question: Now that the Steelers have been effectively shut out of the post season, should they shut down some of their key players for the year. Ben Roethlisberger hasn't looked right most of the year and I doubt that he is 100% given what he has endured. Hines Ward had surgery and even Troy Polamalu has been dinged all year. Rather than play hurt, wouldn't the Steelers be better served to hold these guys out to make sure they are healthy for next year? - Chas Thorp, San Francisco, CA

BOUCHETTE: It would be difficult to go down any NFL roster at this time of the year and find half the starters who don't have some kind of injury or another. Ward won't play, probably for the next two games. Neither will Polamalu. Roethlisberger is healthy so there's no sense in resting him. I agree that in some cases it's better to make some players sit out when your team is hopelessly out of it. But you have to be careful because, as I said, many players are injured and they'll be looking at which ones you want to sit and which ones you want to play. What do you do with players such as Clark Haggans, Jeff Hartings, Dan Kreider, Joey Porter, Casey Hampton, etc.? They've played through injuries much of the season. Plus, some players just don't want to take a rest, they want to play.


Livinginthe past
12-02-2006, 12:18 PM
Using pure logic, it make sense to sit these guys with the chances of progression to the postseason so unlikely.

However, I think the paying customers would be more than a little upset to see the Steelers so obviously throw the towel in on the season.

You know, even though the season is basically over, I still think another blowout by the Ravens and or another loss to the playoff chasing Bengals would hurt the fans.

It doesn't send out the right message to the players either - you never throw the towel in.