View Full Version : 2008 Top 20

03-03-2008, 06:28 AM
I've been trying to compile a top 20 list. I've been able to list 13 players.
I would like everyones help in completing this list.

Now stick with me. There was a game played on the Pitt Steelers forum, that members added or subtracted points from past Steelers to decide the Alltime Steeler. Maybe we could do that to fill in the top 20.

Here's the list I've compiled so far, these players have been in the top 20 since the season ended and the draft process started;

1. Darren McFadden RB
2. Chris Long DE
3. Jake Long OT
4. Glenn Dorsey DT
5. Matt Ryan QB
6. Sedrick Ellis DT
7. Vernon Gholston DE
8. Ryan Clady OT
9. Mike Jenkins CB
10. Malcolm Kelly WR
11. Jonathan Stewart RB
12. Keith Rivers LB
13. DeSean Jackson WR

First off, I'd like to see if everyone agrees with the players listed, Then we can look at other players to round out the top 20.
Some players IMO;

Brian Brohm QB
Leodis McKelvin CB
Aqib Talib CB
D.R. Cromartie CB
Kenny Phillips S
Derrick Harvey DE
Phillip Merling DE
Calais Cambell DE
Quinten Groves DE
Rashard Mendenhall RB
Felix Jones RB
Chris Williams OT
Sam Baker OT
Jeff Otah OT
Dan Connors LB
Kentwan Balmer DT
Limas Sweed WR
James Hardy WR

If someone can help out with the rules and set-up of the game I think it could be interesting and fun. Come on, pitch in.

03-04-2008, 06:02 AM
O.K., people, everyone listen up. Excuse me people! Will everyone get in single file. Don't worry, everyone will get a chance to participate.

I'm glad everyone agreed on the first 13. Now we can get on with finalizing the remaining top 20.

The rules are simple. Copy and paste the list of players to round out the top 20. Each player starts out with 5 points. As you copy and paste the list, subtract a point from a player who you don't think belongs in the top 20 and add it to a player that should be in the top 20. Please only vote once a day!

03-04-2008, 06:07 AM
Brian Brohm QB 5
Leodis McKelvin CB 6
Aqib Talib CB 5
D.R. Cromartie CB 5
Kenny Phillips S 5
Derrick Harvey DE 5
Phillip Merling DE 5
Calais Cambell DE 5
Quinten Groves DE 5
Rashard Mendenhall RB 5
Felix Jones RB 5
Chris Williams OT 5
Sam Baker OT 4
Jeff Otah OT 5
Dan Connors LB 5
Kentwan Balmer DT 5
Limas Sweed WR 5
James Hardy WR 5

-1 Sam Baker
+1 Leodis McKelvin