PDA

View Full Version : No Bradshaw? Sirius QB poll


Vis
07-09-2008, 07:50 AM
http://www.sirius.com/nflgreatest

Can't believe Bradshaw isn't on the list.

revefsreleets
07-09-2008, 08:32 AM
Didn't you read that one blog? Bradshaw is one of the most overrated QB's of all time.:blah:

Dino 6 Rings
07-09-2008, 08:33 AM
Who's Over rated exactly?

How about this stat. QB Rating in the Superbowl.

Terry Bradshaw 1st Superbowl appearance QB Rating 108.0
Tom Brady 1st Superbowl appearance QB Rating 86.2
Joe Montana 1st Superbowl appearance QB Rating 100.0

Terry Bradshaw 2nd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 122.5
Tom Brady 2nd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 100.5
Joe Montana 2nd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 127.2

Terry Bradshaw 3rd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 119.2
Tom Brady 3rd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 110.2
Joe Montana 3rd Superbowl appearance QB Rating 115.2

Terry Bradshaw 4th Superbowl appearance QB Rating 101.9
Tom Brady 4th Superbowl appearance QB Rating 82.5
Joe Montana 4th Superbowl appearance QB Rating 147.6

Mosca
07-09-2008, 08:37 AM
It's tough. But I sure would like to field the team that HAS been chosen. Much as I love Brad, I'd take Unitas over him, without question. And probably Montana, Manning, and Marino. I'd trade Bradshaw even up for Unitas, and I'd even trade Bradshaw in his prime and a first round pick for Unitas in his prime. And I couldn't argue with the rest of the list, either.

But WTF is Dennis Franz doing there at MLB?

Dino 6 Rings
07-09-2008, 08:40 AM
I just sent the Sirius company an email stating that I BAN them from my life until they fix the Poll to include Terry Bradshaw. I included the SB stats that I shared above as well as

TDS Career Superbowl
Terry Bradshaw = 9
Tom Brady = 7
Joe Montana = 11

Fck the haters. I'm going to spend my time attacking the attacks until the off season. Now where is that blog jackhole I have more to send him.

Vis
07-09-2008, 08:45 AM
I just sent the Sirius company an email stating that I BAN them from my life until they fix the Poll to include Terry Bradshaw. I included the SB stats that I shared above as well as

TDS Career Superbowl
Terry Bradshaw = 9
Tom Brady = 7
Joe Montana = 11

Fck the haters. I'm going to spend my time attacking the attacks until the off season. Now where is that blog jackhole I have more to send him.

Ha. I e-mailed them those stats as well. And I challenged them to discount the stats on air.

MDSteel15
07-09-2008, 08:55 AM
Here's my question on the poll, How do you even have Elway on there considering he lost 3 Super Bowls looking like a little beyotch before Terrel Davis won 2 other Super Bowls for him? That is who I call OVERRATED!

Dino 6 Rings
07-09-2008, 08:55 AM
He can't challenge them, they speak for themselves. You can put in any QB that has played in 4 or more superbowls, and Bradshaw is right there second behind Montana. Elway/Kelly/Tarkenton/Staubach, none of the stats like Terry. The only QB in the sport I will ever concede as to having better stats is Montana. However, as I have clearly stated in other posts, being the QB of the Best Dynasty in the NFL makes Terry the best QB ever by default.

CantStop85
07-09-2008, 10:08 AM
Eh, they probably should have included Bradshaw, but he wouldn't have won anyway...that honor should go to Montana.

At least they got the offensive tackle right lol

And is Alan Faneca really the 2nd best guard of all-time?

fansince'76
07-09-2008, 10:22 AM
Ha. I e-mailed them those stats as well. And I challenged them to discount the stats on air.

They'll probably go with the proven CHFF method - use 3 SB wins to hype Brady up as the greatest thing since sliced bread and then when presented with statistics showing Bradshaw outperformed him in the SB, drag his regular season stats (primarily the ones for '07) out.

lamberts-lost-tooth
07-09-2008, 10:38 AM
Eh, they probably should have included Bradshaw, but he wouldn't have won anyway...that honor should go to Montana.

At least they got the offensive tackle right lol

And is Alan Faneca really the 2nd best guard of all-time?

I was more floored by Moss being rated above Carter, Harrison, & Owens...I guess lazy talent is rated over solid production.

CantStop85
07-09-2008, 10:51 AM
I was more floored by Moss being rated above Carter, Harrison, & Owens...I guess lazy talent is rated over solid production.

Yeah, no doubt he's probably the most talented receiver of all-time, but do you rank that above the consistency of guys like Harrison and Carter? *shrugs* If I were building an all-time all-star team, I'd probably take the safe pick of Harrison, but a motivated Randy Moss certainly wouldn't be a bad choice either.

Another head scratcher was Ed Reed at safety...really? Maybe someday, but I don't know if I would ever consider him one of the greatest safeties of all-time.

Dino 6 Rings
07-09-2008, 11:56 AM
They'll probably go with the proven CHFF method - use 3 SB wins to hype Brady up as the greatest thing since sliced bread and then when presented with statistics showing Bradshaw outperformed him in the SB, drag his regular season stats (primarily the ones for '07) out.

The guy lost to Eli Manning, he automatically is out of the Top Spot. You can't lose to your rivals younger brother and still be considered the greatest ever. Sorry but it doesn't work that way.