PDA

View Full Version : Top ten list of NFL's meanest players (3 steelers on the list)


mesaSteeler
05-29-2009, 09:05 AM
Good and nasty: Dahl tops list of NFL's meanest players
May 27, 2009
By Pete Prisco
CBSSports.com Senior Writer
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/story/11793612


FLOWERY BRANCH, Ga. -- As if on cue, the NFL's meanest player, and some might say the league's dirtiest, livened up a ho-hum May practice a few weeks back by doing something he does a lot, which is to brawl.

Atlanta Falcons guard Harvey Dahl is a nasty player who pushes the whistle on almost every play, so it wasn't surprising to see him in the middle of a violent practice fight that ended with Dahl getting eight stitches across his nose, courtesy of a helmet to the face.

Dahl has a knack for getting under the skin of opposing players. (US Presswire)
Dahl has a knack for getting under the skin of opposing players. (US Presswire)
The helmet to the face came when defensive end Kroy Bierman, Dahl's combatant, lunged at Dahl after his helmet came off. It was an accident, not a head-butt you would see in some fake wrestling ring, but it didn't stop Dahl.

Face cut, helmet off, blood rushing down his nose, Dahl kept swinging. And swinging. And swinging.

"You roll with the punches," Dahl said the next day, a bandage covering his stitches, his forehead purple with bruises. "No big deal. Just a practice fight."

Dahl has his share of them, so many that when the fight started, those on the sidelines without a clear view of the number of the offensive player pretty much knew who it was right away.

The chorus was easy to hear: "Harvey."

Dahl is the modern-day Conrad Dobler. Back in the 1970s, Dobler was a mean offensive guard who was considered dirty by many of those who played against him.

Dahl has the same characteristics. Players don't like playing against him. In discussing him with some league personnel, all mentioned that he pushes the limits -- sometimes too far.

Dahl sheepishly admitted it, and thanked me for the comparison to Dobler.

"I push the whistle," he said. "Yeah, definitely. It frustrates guys. But I'm going to go hard all the time. It gets under guy's skin. But I just try and stay focused."

It's how Dahl earned his job in the league. He's not going to change now. He's the classic self-made player. He played at the University of Nevada, but he wasn't drafted. The Dallas Cowboys signed him as a free agent, but he got cut on June 3, 2005 -- several weeks before training camp.

The San Francisco 49ers signed him and he spent most of the next three seasons on their practice squad, although he was activated for a few games. It was there that his brutish style got him noticed.

"I remember I fought [49ers linebacker] Derek Smith in practice one day," Dahl said. "He had just signed a new contract and I was a practice-squad guy, so that was kind of a big deal."

The Falcons signed him to their active roster off the 49ers practice squad in October 2007 and he won a starting job last season. His play last season helped put running back Michael Turner into the Pro Bowl.

Who's the meanest NFL player? Cast your votes now!

"That's my man," Turner said. "He's one of the nasty boys. He's tough, hard-nosed and plays hard. He came from the bottom, so he plays hard all the time. Don't make him mad. That elevates his game even more."

Dahl's teammates say you can see the rage in his face in the huddle when he gets set off. It makes him play better, they say.

"I wouldn't want to line up against him," Falcons quarterback Matt Ryan said. "He's nasty. He's relentless. He plays through the whistle. That's what you want from those guys. He keeps making blocks late in the play."

Is he dirty? The Falcons players all backed their teammate and said no. Opponents might differ.

It was Dahl's tactics in a preseason game last summer against the Tennessee Titans that led to some nasty, chippy stuff that had Titans coach Jeff Fisher screaming across the field at Atlanta coach Mike Smith. Several players from another team agreed that Dahl pushes the limits, and might cross the line. The league office thought he did so three times last season and fined him all three times for it.

"Most of the time I don't go over the line," Dahl said. "Those times, I guess I did."

Dahl isn't just a nasty player -- he's also a good one. His ability to drive block in the run game makes him one of the best guards in the league. His pass protection needs improvement in part because he is so aggressive. The Atlanta coaching staff is trying to get him to improve his footwork in pass protection and keep him from merely attacking on every play. If he does that, this self-made player just might be on his way to the Pro Bowl.

For now, he seems to accept being one of the league's nastiest players as a badge of honor, even if it brings up questions about going too far.

"That's OK by me," he said.

As he said that, Falcons line coach Paul Boudreau walked by to ask what was going on.

Ravens enforcer Ray Lewis remains a lock for nasty lists. (Getty Images)
Ravens enforcer Ray Lewis remains a lock for nasty lists. (Getty Images)
"Just doing on a column on the league's nastiest player," I said.

"Glad we got something," Boudreau said. "We'll take it."

Memo to anybody lining up against the Falcons this year: Keep an eye out for No. 73, even if the play is over.

You might hate him, but the Falcons love their brutish guard.

Here are nine other nasty boys who play the game with ferocity, some who even cross the line on an occasion or two.

Ray Lewis, LB, Baltimore Ravens: He is a violent player who never backs down. Of all the nasty boys, he's by far the best football player. I would take 11 of him on my defense all day long.

Hines Ward, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers: Some say he's dirty -- I say he's close -- but he plays with a passion. If he's on your team, you love him. If he's not, you hate him. He does take his share of cheap shots.

Troy Polamalu, S, Pittsburgh Steelers: He's a big hitter who always seems to take the big shot. He flies to the football. Receivers and runners have to keep their eyes open for him.

Richie Incognito, G, St. Louis Rams: He's a candidate for the league's dirtiest player. He goes nuts on the field, too much in fact. But he insists he will be calmer this season. When he's focused, he can be a good player.

Cortland Finnegan, CB, Tennessee Titans: He's a Pro Bowl corner, but he's also a feisty player whom opponents hate. Watch him as the whistle blows -- he's usually in some kind of fracas. For a 5-foot-9 corner, he sure doesn't back down.

Joey Porter, LB, Miami Dolphins: Some say his bark is bigger than his bite, but he has a heck of a bite. Porter plays the game relentlessly and won't back down from a scuffle. Count on him to be in the middle of most scrums when the Dolphins are playing.

Adrian Wilson, S, Arizona Cardinals: He's a fierce tackler who doesn't back down from anyone. Two years ago, he got flagged for eight personal fouls. Did you see him getting into it with Ward in the Super Bowl? I love the way he plays.

James Harrison, LB, Pittsburgh Steelers: He's meaner than his pit bull, and that's saying something. This guy plays all out all the time. Even some of his teammates are scared of him. In Steelers lore, he is right up there with the meanest, including Mean Joe Greene, Greg Lloyd and Jack Lambert.

Bob Sanders, S, Indianapolis Colts: He's a missile playing safety. He has no regard for his body and none for those he plays against. That's why he's hurt a lot. He's small, but never backs down from a fight or a tackle. It's too bad he has missed so much time in his career.

Runners-up: Chris Snee, G, Giants; David Stewart, T, Titans; Olin Kreutz, C, Bears; Atari Bigby, S, Packers; Marcus Stroud, DT, Bills; Marc Colombo, T, Cowboys; Shawne Merriman, OLB, Chargers; Darnell Dockett, DT, Cardinals; Shaun Rogers, DT, Browns; Andrew Whitworth, G, Bengals; Vince Wilfork, NT, Patriots; Logan Mankins, G, Patriots; Steve Smith, WR, Panthers.

TDLP
05-29-2009, 10:28 AM
Hines Ward maybe, but I wouldn't describe Polamalu as mean, and probably wouldn't include him in a list with just plain nasty guys like Dahl

Tankus_Maximus
05-29-2009, 10:50 AM
Gotta agree that Troy doesn't belong on that list, but it was awesome to see that Harrison is on that list.

Great way to represent Debo!!!!

vasteeler
05-29-2009, 11:13 AM
the discription of ray ray makes me want to :puke:

SCSTILLER
05-29-2009, 11:20 AM
Heck of a compliment to be mentioning Harrison in the same breath as Lambert, Greene, and Lloyd. I think he is deserving of it.

Just like everyone else said, Troy does not belong on that list. Maybe if the list was labelled "best hitters in the NFL" but not meanest.

NEPAsteeler
05-29-2009, 12:05 PM
I don't think Troy has a mean bone in his body. Competitive, definitely. But mean? Absolutely not.

Steely McSmash
05-29-2009, 12:53 PM
I don't think Troy has a mean bone in his body. Competitive, definitely. But mean? Absolutely not.

I agree -- I think they meant this to be hard-hitting not mean. Bob Sanders doesn't strike me as mean either,. Heck of a player but not vindictive.

Polamalu and Ward are not mean, they're hard hitters.

Harrison I would say is perhaps mean.

Colon might be a candidate for 2nd meanest Steeler.

They didn't mention Haynesworth who before being famous for being over-paid was famous for ripping somebody's hellmet off and stomping on their face. Not even an honorable mention??

STEELtownHAVOX
05-29-2009, 03:12 PM
"meaner than his pit bull" that was funny, but i do hope his son gets better.

Psyychoward86
05-29-2009, 05:13 PM
Reminds me of the time Troy insisted that people dont call him the Tasmanian Devil, but the Tasmanian Angel :chuckle:

Vincent
05-29-2009, 05:18 PM
The premise of our 3 guys being among the 10 meanest players in the league is stupid, but no more stupid that saying McStabbin is the best football player. Our 3 are every bit the football player that McStabbin ever was, and now he's old, slow, and out of gas.

You could build a team around any of our three and we have all three.

It has been noted that Troy hasn't a mean bone in his body. He just plays every play to the best of his ability and to hear him tell it, he does it unto the Lord. Nobody with Hines' smile is mean. He just loves football. Silverback might appear to be mean whenever he is in motion, but when the play ends he's patting people and helping them up, You'd NEVER see Lambert, Greene or Lloyd do that. Ever.

MasterOfPuppets
05-29-2009, 05:35 PM
i'd think ryan clark would make this list before troy.....:noidea:

Preacher
05-29-2009, 05:42 PM
I don't know...

Troy has had his share of moments.. like throwing the football at the cincy player in the playoffs, getting a 15 yard penaltiy, and STILL holding them out of the endzone. He is very soft spoken, but ON the field.... well... Watch him when he goes over the top. He usually tackles BY THE NECK. It is brutal.

In short... does anyone else see what I am seeing? All of a sudden, we have two SB's, a QB of legend, LB's that are plain ole Nasty and mean.... oh yeah, and FAST, with one that scares his own players. Two safeties that can both ball hawk AND take off people's heads... and tend to do both. An offense that may not be the best, but can almost ALWAYS get the job done when needed.... and a defense that simply DOMINATES the league...

I look at the calendar and rub my eyes.... Does it say 1979 or 2009??

SunshineMan21
05-29-2009, 06:29 PM
Wow . . . . Ray "by far the best football player?"

That made me giggle a little bit.

fansince'76
05-29-2009, 06:50 PM
Wow . . . . Ray "by far the best football player?"

Best at jumping on the pile after the play is already over and getting credited with 2 solo tackles for it, maybe. :coffee:

MasterOfPuppets
05-29-2009, 07:32 PM
I look at the calendar and rub my eyes.... Does it say 1979 or 2009??

i hope not ....cause that means a 25 year drought is on the horizon....:popcorn:

LVSteelersfan
05-29-2009, 08:23 PM
Ray Lewis the best? Who is this clown? Ray Lewis is not even the 9th best player on that list at this point of his career. And Troy definitely does not belong here. What a joke.

brick
05-30-2009, 12:55 AM
Troy is a lot of things, but mean isn't one of em.

Harrison, on the other hand, would probably make Chuck Norris wet himself if he stared at him hard enough.

stillers4me
05-30-2009, 06:20 AM
Harrison, on the other hand, would probably make Chuck Norris wet himself if he stared at him hard enough.

I'm glad I got to meet the better side of him! He had that steely glare on his face when he walked in the room, but was all smiles and jokes while meeting the fans.

I wouldn't ask him about that trip to Washington, though............ :chuckle:

Hapa
05-30-2009, 10:20 AM
Hines Ward maybe, but I wouldn't describe Polamalu as mean, and probably wouldn't include him in a list with just plain nasty guys like Dahl

Yea Polamalu is definitely relentless... but not mean.

brick
05-30-2009, 10:33 AM
I'm glad I got to meet the better side of him! He had that steely glare on his face when he walked in the room, but was all smiles and jokes while meeting the fans.

I wouldn't ask him about that trip to Washington, though............ :chuckle:
you got to meet silverback? thats awesome, when/where was it?

triphahn
05-30-2009, 05:21 PM
I don't know...

Troy has had his share of moments.. like throwing the football at the cincy player in the playoffs, getting a 15 yard penaltiy, and STILL holding them out of the endzone. He is very soft spoken, but ON the field.... well... Watch him when he goes over the top. He usually tackles BY THE NECK. It is brutal.

In short... does anyone else see what I am seeing? All of a sudden, we have two SB's, a QB of legend, LB's that are plain ole Nasty and mean.... oh yeah, and FAST, with one that scares his own players. Two safeties that can both ball hawk AND take off people's heads... and tend to do both. An offense that may not be the best, but can almost ALWAYS get the job done when needed.... and a defense that simply DOMINATES the league...

I look at the calendar and rub my eyes.... Does it say 1979 or 2009??

I hear you. If our offensive line becomes dominant or at least top 10 in the league we could be looking at one of the best ever.

Galax Steeler
05-31-2009, 08:30 AM
Troy is the man but not mean he is not a dirty player. He is a hard hitter and a good player.

rich4eagle
05-31-2009, 07:49 PM
Hines Ward maybe, but I wouldn't describe Polamalu as mean, and probably wouldn't include him in a list with just plain nasty guys like Dahl

The Answer to the question is a joke........instead of naming the meanest players.......often it was the best of breed players on defense

the whole question is essentially stupid....................

a better question is who are the most "feared" players

meanjoecoop
06-02-2009, 10:06 PM
It takes a special kind of "Mean" to rip someones head off and then kneel down next to them and say a prayer for them...Troy belongs. :chuckle:

http://surf.transworld.net/files/2009/02/06/troy-polamalu.jpg

Sharkissle29
06-03-2009, 12:35 AM
Where is Ryan Clark?!?!