View Full Version : Toronto/Calgary Trade

01-31-2010, 12:24 PM

Toronto Maple Leafs General Manager Brian Burke has seen enough of his underachieving club.

Sunday morning, Burke remade the Maple Leafs with a bold move and a hint of more to come.

"We are in buying and selling mode," Burke said during his morning press conference to announce a deal for defenseman Dion Phaneuf, who come aboard with two other players from the Calgary Flames in exchange for four players.

The complete deal was Phaneuf, right wing Fredrik Sjostrom and prospect Keith Aulie to Toronto for forwards Niklas Hagman, Matt Stajan, Jamal Mayers and defenseman Ian White.

Calgary, which defeated Edmonton Saturday night for its first win in 10 games, had been working with the Leafs on the framework of this deal for more than a week.

Phaneuf is the big, physically dominating defenseman who defines Burke's philosophy. Burke thought he had obtained that player in the summer, signing Montreal's Mike Komisarek to a free-agent deal. But Komisarek's season has been derailed by a slow start and a shoulder injury.

"He is a warrior," Burke said of Phaneuf. "He's got a cannon for a shot. He plays the game hard and I want players who play the game hard because they're hard to play against."

Now, the hard-hitting Phaneuf, drafted by the Flames in the first round, No. 9, in 2003, gets his chance to do that for Burke

Phaneuf has 10 goals and 12 assists with a plus- 3 rating in 55 games this season. Those numbers are respectable, but he has spent some time in the doghouse of first-year coach Brent Sutter. Plus, Calgary was looking to make a deal after struggling throughout the month of January.

The Maple Leafs have struggled all season and may have hit rock bottom less than 24 hours earlier when they blew a 3-0 lead at home in dropping a 5-3 decision to Vancouver.

Toronto sits in the basement of the Eastern Conference with just 17 wins and 45 points this season and it has allowed an NHL-worse 197 goals.

It appears Burke also is looking to reshape his goaltending picture. Several outlets are reporting that the Maple Leafs are landing Jean-Sebastien Giguere from the Anaheim Ducks, Burke's most recent post before assuming the reigns in Toronto last season.

Giguere has to waive his no-trade clause in his contract for the move to happen, but, certainly, the chance to be reunited with Burke and goalie coach Francois Allaire made that more palatable.

Giguere, 32, is the winningest goalie in Ducks history and led the franchise to its only Stanley Cup title in 2007, but he and his hefty contract became excess to needs with the emergence of Swiss goalie Jonas Hiller, who not only stole the No. 1 job, but just signed a four-year contract extension this week.

Giguere was the only player left from Anaheim's trip to the 2003 Stanley Cup Final, where he was voted the Conn Smythe Trophy despite being on the losing end of a seven-game decision to New Jersey.

In the Phaneuf deal, the Maple Leafs also get Sjostrom, a veteran winger who has played 46 games with 1 goal and 5 assists for Calgary this season. But it may be Aulie who defines the long-term success of this deal. A fourth-round pick in the 2007 Entry Draft, Aulie is another big, shutdown defenseman. He was used effectively in that role during his World Junior Championship appearance for Team Canada. This season, Aulie (6-foot-6) is with the Abbotsford Heat of the AHL.

Calgary, meanwhile, gets a ton of scoring depth and an underrated offensive defenseman in White, who is a little on the small side. White has 9 goals, 17 assists and a plus-1 rating in 56 games. His 26 points are four more than Phaneuf has put up this season.

Hagman has 20 goals and 13 assists, while Stajan has 16 goals and 25 assists this season. Stajan is an unrestricted free agent at the end of the season. Each has played 55 games. Mayers has 2 goals 6 assists and 78 penalty minutes during 44 games. He recently asked to be traded.

01-31-2010, 01:11 PM
The Leafs did end up landing Giguere...they sent Jason Blake and Vesa Toskala to the Ducks for him.

I'm not sure what to make of the Leafs/Flames deal. Dion Phaneuf has really been a disappointment the last 2 seasons, even more so this season, didn't get along with Brent Sutter, and the Flames desperately needed some scoring depth to make a push for the playoffs. Matt Stajan will be immediately inserted on the top line with Jarome Iginla, and Niklas Hagman will give them some scoring depth on the 2nd line. Ian White is the kind of gritty defenseman that Sutter likes and he'll get a lot of the ice time that Phaneuf got. And Jamal Mayers will bring more toughness to an already tough lineup. Brian Burke loves physical defensemen, and when he is on his game, Phaneuf definitely provides that. The Leafs did trade away pretty much all of their scoring (and thank God Blake is in the West now - that guy has KILLED the Pens over the years), but they still have Kessel, Ponikarovsky, Grabovski, a couple of young, up-and-coming forwards, and if Phaneuf gets back to his Norris Trophy candidate form from a couple years ago, that will make the deal better for Toronto.

As for the Ducks trade, obviously Blake was thrown into the deal so that Burke would agree to take Giguere and his $7 million salary off the Ducks' hands. Jonas Hiller got a new contract yesterday, guaranteeing him the #1 job, so you knew Giguere would eventually be dealt.

Look for the Leafs to trade Tomas Kaberle either by the deadline or this summer for some scoring help. Phaneuf coming to TO makes him expendable.