PDA

View Full Version : The Combine Fallacy


Galax Steeler
03-01-2010, 05:23 AM
The NFL Scouting Combine began on Thursday. It is an annual ritual in which scouts, coaches, and team general managers come to Indianapolis to watch potential NFL players do a bunch of things that have almost nothing to do with football.

ďNothing to do with Football?!!!Ē, you say, ďThe 40 yard dash has everything to do with football. We need to see if the guys that we draft are fast!Ē

That statement might be true if you were Al Davis. But for the rest of the sane world, the 40 yard dash is a useless measure. How often does a football player run 40 yards? Not many. How often does an offensive lineman run 40 yards? Never.

Donít believe me? Letís take a look at the season that just ended. During the 2009 regular season, Peyton Manning completed a total of 8 passes for 40 yards or more. Thatís right, 8. Out of 571 pass attempts. Thatís 1.4% of his passes. Drew Brees completed 11 passes for over 40 yards. Kurt Warner completed a whopping 3 passes for 40 yards or more.

We all know that Steelers offensive coordinator Bruce Arians is in love with the long pass, but even Ben Roethlisberger only completed 14 passes for 40 yards or more. Thatís out of 506 pass attempts. Starting to get the picture? NFL players donít run 40 yards.

A waste of time

Even kick returners and punt returners donít break many returns for 40 yards. And when they do, is it ever in a straight line? Do they ever start from a track runnersí starting position? Nope.

How about the shuttle run? Does that drill emulate anything that youíve ever seen in a football game? Didnít think so.

Same with the vertical leap. When was the last time you saw a player jump straight up in the air from a standing position? What insight will we gain about Terrence Cody when we see that his vertical leap is an awe-inspiring 4 millimeters?

And I donít even want to talk about how stupid the Wonderlic Test is. Click here to see a sample Wonderlic Test. Now tell me what the #$%*&@!# that has to do with football? What would you have done if your job had made you take that test before they hired you? Does the term ďgo postalĒ sound familiar?

Yet despite how silly the NFL Scouting Combine really is, it has become a made-for-TV event that is aired on NFL Network. People actually stay home from work so they can watch this crap.

Message boards all over the internet will be littered with discussions about how fast a certain receiver is, or how many times a certain linemen bench pressed 225 lbs.

I remember a couple of years ago the Steelers picked up a guy named Mike Kudla who did an amazing 45 reps on the bench press. Steelers fans on message boards were doing backflips over the guy. I remember several Steelers fans even predicting that Kudla was a sure Hall-of-Famer. Unfortunately, Kudla never played a regular season game in the NFL. Itís too bad the NFL doesnít use a bench press competition to determine the winner of overtime games. If they did, Kudla would still be in the league.

I also remember Steelers fans tirelessly advocating that the Steelers select Jarron Gilbert with their first pick last year. Most of them had never actually seen him play. Not a single down. But what they had seen was a YouTube video of Gilbert jumping out of a swimming pool. Yeah, players do that all the time during the course of a game. In case youíre wondering, Gilbert started no games this season, made appearances in 4 games, and accumulated a total of 1 tackle. So much for jumping out of swimming pools.

Itís one thing when casual fans make the mistake of falling in love with workout wonders. But itís a sin when NFL officials do it. Thatís exactly what happened last year when the Oakland Raiders made Darrius Heyward-Bey the first receiver drafted. Heyward-Bey ran a blistering time in the 40 yard dash, and that was all Al Davis needed to see. However, if Davis had bothered to review actual game tape of Heyward-Bey, he would have noticed that he canít catch. Thatís a bit of a problem for a wide receiverÖÖÖ..even if he is fast.

Fortunately for Steelers fans, Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin donít seem to fall into the trap of falling in love with workout wonders. They are very disciplined in their approach and seldom make early round draft mistakes.

I just wish they could say the same thing about their later round picks.

http://steelerstoday.com/

Steeldude
03-01-2010, 05:52 AM
they must use the tests for something. otherwise they would never hold a combine.

i like the wonderlic test. i would like to know if the player i am drafting is an idiot or intelligent. would a team draft a QB with a 2 on the wonderlic?

steeldawg
03-01-2010, 06:29 AM
they must use the tests for something. otherwise they would never hold a combine.

i like the wonderlic test. i would like to know if the player i am drafting is an idiot or intelligent. would a team draft a QB with a 2 on the wonderlic?

I think Vince Young scored a 6. :thumbsup:

Chidi29
03-01-2010, 07:43 PM
The Combine is most useful for interviews and medical evaluations.

43Hitman
03-01-2010, 08:20 PM
The Combine is most useful for interviews and medical evaluations.

And flexibility. As in ankle flextion(sp) and the way a player drops his hips to make a change in direction.