PDA

View Full Version : Rank the 10 best Steeler players


Gnutella
03-04-2010, 11:37 AM
The 10 best Steeler players

1. Troy Polamalu
2. Ben Roethlisberger
3. James Harrison
4. Aaron Smith
5. Heath Miller
6. Casey Hampton
7. LaMarr Woodley
8. Hines Ward
9. Jeff Reed
10. Rashard Mendenhall

supa_fly_steeler
03-04-2010, 11:44 AM
1. Troy Polamalu
2. Aaron Smith *underrated as hell*
3. Ben Roethlisberger
4. LaMarr Woodley
5. James Harrison
6. Hines Ward
7. Casey Hampton
8. Heath Miller
9. Santonio Holmes
10. Tyrone Carter :chuckle:

truesteelerfan
03-04-2010, 12:36 PM
1. Troy
2. Ben
3. Hines
4. Heath
5. Harrison
6. Woodley
7. Smith
8. Santonio
9. Rashard
10. Clark

wootawnee
03-04-2010, 12:53 PM
I cannot say best....but in order to win championships, this is my picks...........

1...Ben
2...Troy
3...Silverback
4...Hines
4.5...Potsie
5...Ike
6...Woodley
7...Snack...
8...Smitty
9...Tone
10....Max....
10.5....Heath
10.6....Kiesel
10.7....Colon
10.8...Timmons

In 08 we could of had 4 Troys, but no one in the league goes 92 yards in 2+minutes but Ben........
Potsie is moving down just because of age......Oh well we all get old like beer, not wine........
I could move Heath around a bit on my list.......I don't think he would care where you would put him, his ego is so small he might not even have one.......He probably wouldn't care if his name was not on the team roster in the programs they give out at the Stadium on game day.........
Max could be higher...(people just don't understand)........Colon should be on this list as well as the big boy Kemo......
Oops...I guess I squeezed Willie on there.........The Bronx Brawler.......He is going up this list..........So is Timmons.,.If we can ever use him in the most optimum way.......

All in all you gotta earn your way on this list..........

But in all honesty.....Brad said it best to Mean Joe......"You can win with me, but You can never win without me."....
That is why is Ben #1

+NuBbS+
03-04-2010, 12:55 PM
1. Troy
2. Ben
3. Big Snack
4. Hines
5. Harrison
6. Woodley
7. Holmes
8. Starks
9. Aaron Smith
10.Heath

kirklandrules
03-04-2010, 01:12 PM
1. Ben
2. Troy
3. Big Snack
4. Woodley
5. Harrison
6. Aaron Smith
7. Holmes
8. Hines
9. Mendenhall
10.Heath

I also believe Timmons will be on this list ... but maybe next year's version. To this point, he hasn't performed in the top 10. I probably would have place Kemo on the list if he wasn't fighting injuries this year. He's our best O-lineman.

MDSteel15
03-04-2010, 01:37 PM
How about 5 best on offense and defense?

Offense
1. Ben Roethlisberger
2. Hines Ward
3. Heath Miller
4. Mike Wallace
5. Rashard Mendenhall

Defense
1. Troy Polamalu
2. LaMarr Woodley
3. Aaron Smith
4. James Harrison
5. Casey Hampton

Vincent
03-04-2010, 01:52 PM
Assuming by "players" you mean F'BALL players

Troy **
Ben
Mendy.- watch what this kid does this year.
Silverback
Aaron **
Ryan
Lamarr
Hines
Heath
Ike
Wallace
Tone

Honorable mention - Potsy - HM only because he's getting old
** Troy and Aaron missed so much that they should be asterisked, but still ranked. So I added two.

steelerdude15
03-04-2010, 03:04 PM
1. Ben
2. Troy
3. James
4. LaMarr
5. Santonio
6. Hines
7. Heath
8. Aaron
9. Mendy
10. Mike

7SteelGal43
03-04-2010, 03:08 PM
Pick any 10 from the 70s Steelers :tt03:










ohhh, you mean current Steelers, my bad.

JEFF4i
03-04-2010, 03:27 PM
I'm going for players specifically. Impact differs on position but won't be factored here, hence my top 2 designation...

1. Troy
2. Ben
3. Mendy (lil biased, but I think this kid is great, and will be)
4. Harrison
5. Woodley
6. Ward
7. Miller
8. Smith
9. Holmes
10. Timmons

Psyychoward86
03-04-2010, 06:20 PM
1) Troy Polamalu
2) Aaron Smith
3) Casey Hampton
4) Heath Miller
5) Hines Ward
6) James Harrison
7) Ben Roethlisberger
8) Jeff Reed
9) Lamaar Woodley
10) Rashard Mendenhall


this is for the '09 season for me '09

solardave
03-05-2010, 08:39 AM
Troy
Ben
Aaron
Lamar
James
Heath
Hines
Santonio
Wallace
Rashard

With Rashard moving way up after this breakout year.

StainlessStill
03-05-2010, 09:58 AM
Lets see what we got here:

1. Troy Polamalu
2. Ben Roethlisberger
3. Hines Ward
4. James Harrison
5. Aaron Smith
6. Casey Hampton
7. Heath Miller
8. Santonio Holmes
9. LaMarr Woodley
10. Rashard Mendenhall
------------------------------------
NEXT 5:

11- Ike Taylor
12. James Farrior
13. Lawrence Timmons
14. Mike Wallace
15. Jeff Reed

zulater
03-05-2010, 12:23 PM
1. tie Ben
1. tie Troy
3. Woodley
4. Harrison
5. Holmes
6. Heath
7. Aaron
8. Mendenhall
9. Hines
10. Casey

pete74
03-05-2010, 12:55 PM
Assuming by "players" you mean F'BALL players

Troy **
Ben
Mendy.- watch what this kid does this year.
Silverback
Aaron **
Ryan
Lamarr
Hines
Heath
Ike
Wallace
Tone

Honorable mention - Potsy - HM only because he's getting old
** Troy and Aaron missed so much that they should be asterisked, but still ranked. So I added two.

i think mendenhall will do the same thing he did last year if he has to run behind that same line. we need iupati to run behind if we want to get better on the ground. you can put chris johnson in our backfield and he sure the hell wont gain 1500 yards let alone 2000 with our line

RoethlisBURGHer
03-05-2010, 01:03 PM
1.1 - Troy Polamalu
1.2 - Ben Roethlisberger
3 - Casey Hampton
4 - Aaron Smith
5 - Santonio Holmes
6 - Hines Ward
7 - Lamarr Woodley
8 - James Harrison
9 - Rashard Mendenhall
10 - Max Starks

Nadroj 20
03-05-2010, 01:10 PM
1.) Troy
2.) Ben
3.) Woodley
4.) Ward
5.) Harrison
6.) Smith
7.) Miller
8.) Tone
9.) Hampton
10.) Mendy

canadasteel
03-07-2010, 08:45 AM
1 Ben
2 Troy
3 A Smith
4 Hampton
5 Silverback
6 Holmes
7 Woodley
8 Mendenhall
9 Ward
10 Reed
We sucked without Troy last year but we managed to win 9 games. Without Ben we would be hard pressed to win 6!

IamTheSteelGod
03-09-2010, 03:12 AM
Polamalu
Smith
Ward
Harrison
Miller
Farrior
Roethlisberger
Woodley
Hampton
Holmes

Mags87
03-09-2010, 03:23 AM
i dont see how people are putting Ben above Troy. IMO, Troy does what he does better than anyone else in the league besides Peyton Manning. Troy as a safety is WAY better than Ben is a quarterback. (this is not coming from Ben's recent trouble, but an honest opinion)

honestly, u ask anyone who they would want as a safety, Polamalu is number one right now (prolly top 3 ever) in the NFL. Ask about a QB, well Ben just isn't THAT good.

rich4eagle
03-09-2010, 05:52 PM
1. Ben
2. Troy
3. James
4. LaMarr
5. Santonio
6. Hines
7. Heath
8. Aaron
9. Mendy
10. Mike


I like your picks rational objective to winning fans cannot argue much....................

A Safety can never be the most valuable player..........Sorry Troy it is what it is

Unless you score you lose............how bout that for simple:tt04::tt::tt03::tt02::drink:

Mags87
03-10-2010, 01:07 PM
I like your picks rational objective to winning fans cannot argue much....................

A Safety can never be the most valuable player..........Sorry Troy it is what it is

Unless you score you lose............how bout that for simple:tt04::tt::tt03::tt02::drink:

did you see what happened to our D w/o troy?

supa_fly_steeler
03-10-2010, 01:09 PM
you win to play the game - herm edwards

1. troy polamalu