PDA

View Full Version : Steelers unprepared for Superdome noise


mesaSteeler
11-02-2010, 08:14 AM
Steelers unprepared for Superdome noise
Tuesday, November 02, 2010
By Ed Bouchette, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/10306/1099967-66.stm

Defensive lineman Will Smith had one of three of the Saints' sacks against Steelers quarterback Beth Roethlisberger Sunday.

What had become a cozy home-away-from-home feeling abandoned the Steelers Sunday night in what Mike Tomlin correctly called a "hostile environment" that apparently caught players and coaches off-guard and left them confused.

The Steelers had won four consecutive road games as they pulled into New Orleans, some of them before their loud and adoring road-warrior fans, who poured out for both games in Florida, Tampa and Miami. The Superdome was different.

As usual, many Steelers fans attended, and they made their presence known. But Saints fans overwhelmed them, and Tomlin and the players cited the noise as a factor in the 20-10 loss.

"It was worse than Indianapolis in 2005 the first time we played them," offensive tackle Max Starks said, referring to the infamous game in the Colts' old indoor arena in which the Steelers alleged crowd noise was illegally amplified by the home team.

Starks said the noise almost was unexpected and made it sound as if the players were unprepared for it.

"The communication aspect of it is what kind of gets lost," Starks said. "You try to make calls. If someone is making a call on the right side of the line and you try to hear it on the left side, it gets pretty tough and the center can't pass that down because he usually has his head between his legs waiting for the quarterback.

"It's a tough situation to get in. We finally figured out a way to do that and overcame it. But we didn't overcome it quick enough."

No one on the Steelers' side -- players nor coaches on the field nor the sideline and particularly not the coaches in the box upstairs who have television replays in front of them -- raised an issue on Rashard Mendenhall's run on second down on the first goal-line series of the game, in the second quarter. Mendenhall appeared to get the ball over the line, or at least on it.

Even though Tomlin wasted an earlier replay challenge on a non-fumble by New Orleans that replay quickly showed was clearly a non-fumble, he took a pass on using his final replay challenge that might have resulted in a 7-0 Steelers lead.

"When you're on the road, you don't get the [good] looks at replays," Tomlin said. "I didn't get that sense from our guys, particularly Rashard that he thought he was in, so I didn't challenge."

Home scoreboards rarely show a replay to help the visiting team decide if it should challenge the call. NBC-TV, however, showed a fine shot of Mendenhall crossing the goal line and did so in a timely manner. All the coaches in the box would have had to do was watch and tell their head coach to challenge.

Confusion seemed to reign in the 'Dome, the Steelers' first indoors game since they struggled to win in Detroit Oct. 11, 2009.

With a first down as close to the goal line as possible, the Steelers opted not for the safe and usually effective quarterback sneak in that situation, but instead ran Isaac Redman off the right side. Right guard Trai Essex, getting his first start after missing the previous four games with a sprained ankle, said he blew his assignment on that play, and Redman was blown up for a two-yard loss.

After Mendenhall's run that should have been reviewed, he lost nearly a yard on third down, and Tomlin decided to kick a field goal on fourth down at the one.

Starks said the offense eventually "calmed down" from all the confusion "and we started playing a lot better. It was just too little, too late in a lot of instances, especially down at the goal line early on. That was likely a difference-maker as well."

The Saints' defense did a good impersonation of a Dick LeBeau-led Steelers unit, with their well-regarded coordinator Greg Williams adding to the confusion. Even though the Saints were without their starting two cornerbacks and lost rookie No. 3 corner Patrick Robinson for awhile, the Steelers were unable to take advantage, especially not by throwing anything deep. And they could do little against the blitzes Williams sent against them.

Chris Kemoeatu seemed to misidentify one Saints "game" on the line, missed a block and Ben Roethlisberger paid for it with one of three sacks. Rookie Emmanuel Sanders did not recognize a "hot" on a blitz and, as a result, got in the way of a pass that Roethlisberger intended for Hines Ward, and it fell incomplete. That occurred when Tomlin, his team trailing by just three in the third quarter, decided to go for it on fourth-and-four at the New Orleans 40.

"They did a lot of different schemes," Ward explained. "They were getting pressure on Ben, we were trying to figure out what they were trying to do to us, made us hurry up a couple throws. They had a great scheme. "I think we adjusted in the second half, came out and moved the ball better than we did in the first half. But we knew it was going to be tough -- the defending world champs, Halloween night -- I saw so many costumes in the stands -- and they lost to Cleveland last week."
Gibson goes to 49ers

Linebacker Thaddeus Gibson was awarded to the San Francisco 49ers on a waiver claim Monday after the Steelers released their fourth-round pick Saturday. Both the 49ers and the Philadelphia Eagles put in claims for Gibson, who was awarded to San Francisco based on a worse won-loss record this season. The Steelers released Gibson to make room for defensive lineman Steve McLendon, signed from their practice squad.
Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com.


Read more: http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/10306/1099967-66.stm#ixzz147ASoymu

Whodis
11-02-2010, 08:49 AM
So th moral of the story is...... The coaching staff was not excpecting noise, in a dome, on Sunday night? I'm speechless

lionslicer
11-02-2010, 11:33 AM
So th moral of the story is...... The coaching staff was not excpecting noise, in a dome, on Sunday night? I'm speechless

Not many coaches prepare players for noisey stadiums.. I find it stupid.. But I think it just escapes their mind.

What Bill Bellichick does, that isn't cheating, is during every practice, he gets a huge PA system and blasts music the entire practice to get players used to the noise. Depending on where they are playing, he'll make it louder or lowwer. I think more coaches should do this, but they don't.

Whodis
11-02-2010, 01:06 PM
Not many coaches prepare players for noisey stadiums.. I find it stupid.. But I think it just escapes their mind.

.

I remember the super bowl year we had sort of the same situation in Indy. I just didn't think I would ever see the excuse again. The word "STUPID" is so fitting for anything we've done offensively all year. I'm glad to see the Browns coaching staff was able to prepare for it. Maybe our offensive coaching staff can take notes from such a great organization. It's not like Tomlin came from a team that played in a dome and never seen this before.

lionslicer
11-02-2010, 01:12 PM
I remember the super bowl year we had sort of the same situation in Indy. I just didn't think I would ever see the excuse again. The word "STUPID" is so fitting for anything we've done offensively all year. I'm glad to see the Browns coaching staff was able to prepare for it. Maybe our offensive coaching staff can take notes from such a great organization. It's not like Tomlin came from a team that played in a dome and never seen this before.

Defense in general doesn't care since they use hand signals most of the time, but offense only has so many hand signals, a lot of it is vocals. But it gets so loud that you can't even talk to each other in a huddle. Arians coached for the colts, he knows the dome noise. Tomlin only coached defense for 1 year with the vikings, you'd think he'd know about the noise. Its just poor preperation on the coaching staffs part.

Atlanta Dan
11-02-2010, 01:23 PM
I also recall the crowd noise at Indy during the 2005 season being a big issue - after the Steelers lost the Monday night game in late November that season there were stories on Indy cranking up artificial crowd noise on the loudspeakers - Steelers made a point that they had practiced the silent count to deal with the noise when they came back and pulled the playoff upset approximately 6 weeks later - I guess Coach Whiz and Coach Cowher took the Steelers knowledge of how to work around crowd noise with them when they packed up

Just further evidence the team was not ready for Sunday night on mattters beyond not knowing how to hadle the Saints blitz packages

lionslicer
11-02-2010, 01:30 PM
Just further evidence the team was not ready for Sunday night on mattters beyond not knowing how to hadle the Saints blitz packages

I think the noise could haev something to do with it. Neither Pouncy or Ben can call line plays or change the protection. Well they can try, but when the play starts, if 1 guy didn't hear the play, you'll have confusion all over the line. People think offensive linemen just come off the line and block whoever.. no the play calls for them to block certain people and do certain things. At a point I saw the Steelers had 7 or 8 guys blocking for Ben, max protection, but they seemed confused and 2 blitzers, out of 6 got through. So that means 2-3 blockers totally missed their blocks most likely because they didn't know what was going on.

stb_steeler
11-02-2010, 02:14 PM
No excuses, this team should know what to expect going into NO. This team should have practiced this time an time again. If its a lack of preparation then its the coach's fault, plain and simple.

Raw Steel
11-02-2010, 02:14 PM
Steelers unprepared for Superdome noise

No one on the Steelers' side -- players nor coaches on the field nor the sideline and particularly not the coaches in the box upstairs who have television replays in front of them -- raised an issue on Rashard Mendenhall's run on second down on the first goal-line series of the game, in the second quarter. Mendenhall appeared to get the ball over the line, or at least on it.

Even though Tomlin wasted an earlier replay challenge on a non-fumble by New Orleans that replay quickly showed was clearly a non-fumble, he took a pass on using his final replay challenge that might have resulted in a 7-0 Steelers lead.

"When you're on the road, you don't get the [good] looks at replays," Tomlin said. "I didn't get that sense from our guys, particularly Rashard that he thought he was in, so I didn't challenge."

Home scoreboards rarely show a replay to help the visiting team decide if it should challenge the call. NBC-TV, however, showed a fine shot of Mendenhall crossing the goal line and did so in a timely manner. All the coaches in the box would have had to do was watch and tell their head coach to challenge.



So why did you challenge the first one? Not smart. It was obvious yet they challenge it and lose and then the second one was obvious as well and they don't challenge.

Bad coaching.

Fire Haley
11-02-2010, 02:39 PM
Horrible coaching the whole game, and he laughs it off.

Gruden is looking better and better.

fer522
11-02-2010, 02:44 PM
i'll put this loss on the coaching staff
i just hope that they'll learn from it so that
they'll be ready for whatever comes their way next