PDA

View Full Version : How to classify this win


Stillers2012
11-05-2012, 01:51 AM
I just got done watching today's game against the Giants (had to work during the game) and after watching all these rediculous flags I don't know if we should consider this a 24-6 win over the GIants or a 24-20 win over the Giants and the officials 'cause even Phil Simms called all those calls the refs made (Ryan Clark's call, Ben's non-tuck rule, the clip on Heath, etc, etc) terrible calls. But I'm sure Roger Godell and his band of cronies will be up all night trying to figure out how to explain them all off.

WVABE
11-05-2012, 05:35 AM
I thought it was great, even Phil Simms called out the refs.

ChristianKustomz
11-05-2012, 05:54 AM
It's easy to classify the game..."SET UP"! "RIGGED"! "PAID OFF"! "SLANTED"! "ONE SIDED"!

Even when we were "Facing The Giants" like the movie we beat back that brick wall till it collapsed! I LOVED this win today! It showed the world what we are really made of. I hope we win this years SuperBowl do we can shove that 7th ring right in Goodells face and say "YOU CAN'T STOP THE COLORS" or maybe "THESE COLORS DON'T RUN" or something catchy like that to let him know we beat the best, overcame with adversity and persevered even when we were deliberately set up!

The fact is our team has the most SuperBowl rings in the entire NFL's history and they can't take that away!

Classify? Yeah I'll classify! Classify this as a GREAT win!

torpedoshell31
11-05-2012, 06:14 AM
Instead of shoving a ring in Goodell's face, we should have Harrison shove the Lombardi trophy up somewhere else on Goodell's anatomy.

VaDave
11-05-2012, 06:40 AM
RE: Where to place the Lombardi trophy

Lends new definition to the term "Big Sticky"....

RE: Game Clasifcation:

One Win. Fun for us fans, no doubt, but in the overall scheme of things, it's just one win. Right now we better be thing about nothing else but the Chiefs.... Next!

WVABE
11-05-2012, 08:15 AM
Yup, Chiefs suppose to be one of the worst teams, like Oakland & Tennessee.

Blitzberg06
11-05-2012, 08:19 AM
Great win in a must win situation.


I'm more excited about the defense playing. Lewis (besides the one terrible P.I call..the 2nd one. where he was practically hugging the guy) is playing great for us. Linebackers are stepping up. D Line is playing great. Offense is looking lights out. One man goes down and another just steps up and goes. Mike Adams struggled but that was expected..I like his developement so far. Ben is looking AMAZING and on 3rd down it's almost a given that they will convert.


:tt03:

steelfury02
11-05-2012, 08:30 AM
I'll give Giants the benefit of the doubt with the tuck (which still is iffy) and say we should have won 24-13. The call on Clark was probably top 3 worst calls against a Steeler ever. If Ben doesn't throw the pick it could have at least been 27-13 or 31-13.

We physically outmatched them, which is what I expect from a team that is going to contend. Now, we need to get the win and stay healthy this coming week. Can't be looking ahead at all. They really haven't done anything, but are certainly on the right track.

Terminator
11-05-2012, 08:36 AM
The scoreboard doesn't tell the true story. The stats do. We utterly dominated New York in every single category. I truly think we wipped their ass, nice and good.

Big win against the defending SuperBowl champs, and on the road. Can't ask for better than that.

FanSince72
11-05-2012, 08:38 AM
I thought it was great, even Phil Simms called out the refs.

Simms called out a ref?
When?
I guess I missed that one.

Phil Simms has spent the better part of his broadcasting career playing it safe and acting as a tool for the League and wouldn't step in to a controversy even with Goodell's permission, so I'd love to know what he said!

He was silent on the PI call that helped set up the Giants' first score. He even said that he wasn't going to "get into" whether or not it was a good call.

WTF?

If you don't address THAT, then what was there to talk about?
That call sucked and everyone who saw it knew that!

Blitzberg06
11-05-2012, 08:41 AM
Simms called out a ref?
When?
I guess I missed that one.

Phil Simms has spent the better part of his broadcasting career playing it safe and acting as a tool for the League and wouldn't step in to a controversy even with Goodell's permission, so I'd love to know what he said!

He was silent on the PI call that helped set up the Giants' first score. He even said that he wasn't going to "get into" whether or not it was a good call.

WTF?

If you don't address THAT, then what was there to talk about?
That call sucked and everyone who saw it knew that!

That's his way of saying "What the hell?"

BKAnthem
11-05-2012, 08:48 AM
Damn Keenan Lewis has stepped it up this year...Mike Adams needs to get his ass back in the weight room or work on his hand punch, something....... JPP was tossing him around everytime he moved to his side

El-Gonzo Jackson
11-05-2012, 10:37 AM
I thought it was great, even Phil Simms called out the refs.

YES, I give Simms a lot of credit for saying what he did about the PI call on Lewis, the "hit to the head" on Clark, the "tuck rule" non call and the no call on the "block in the back" on the return.

Make no mistake...Phil Simms is a NYG hall of fame QB and a professional broadcaster trying to point out bad calls while not insulting the NFL and its officials that so many fans insisted that the NFL open its wallets for.

Simms called that game objectively, whereas Dan Fouts sounded like a Raiders homer when the Steelers played the Raiders.

Great job Phil Simms :hatsoff:

El-Gonzo Jackson
11-05-2012, 10:39 AM
Damn Keenan Lewis has stepped it up this year...Mike Adams needs to get his ass back in the weight room or work on his hand punch, something....... JPP was tossing him around everytime he moved to his side

Yeah, I am glad to see Lewis playing well. I thought we had a great draft when we got Hood, Urbik, Lewis, Wallace with our first 4 picks.

I still wish we kept Kraig Urbik.

FanSince72
11-05-2012, 10:46 AM
How to classify this win?

Well...I hate this phrase but it was a "Steeler Football" win.
Working with what was given to us, taking chances when necessary, a solid running game and solid defense.

Classic Steelers.

Brett Cottrell
11-05-2012, 10:47 AM
I'd rather classify the craziest, ugliest, worst-officiated win than any loss.

stb_steeler
11-05-2012, 10:47 AM
Simms called out a ref?
When?
I guess I missed that one.

Phil Simms has spent the better part of his broadcasting career playing it safe and acting as a tool for the League and wouldn't step in to a controversy even with Goodell's permission, so I'd love to know what he said!

He was silent on the PI call that helped set up the Giants' first score. He even said that he wasn't going to "get into" whether or not it was a good call.

WTF?

If you don't address THAT, then what was there to talk about?
That call sucked and everyone who saw it knew that!

The only thing i remember Simms saying is he wont interfere with the refs calls...what a tard!

Hawaii 5-0
11-06-2012, 09:18 PM
Kovacevic: The Steelers are back ... right?

By Dejan Kovacevic
Updated: Monday, November 5, 2012

EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. — The Steelers are back.

There really is no other way to put it, right?

Not after they set down the Super Bowl champion Giants, 24-20, Sunday, thanks to a fabulous fourth quarter that was the antithesis of all those early-season collapses.

Not after they avoided getting flustered by some of the worst officiating you’ll see in one half of football.

Not after they shrugged off what should have been a backbreaker of a decision by Mike Tomlin to have his, um, kicker try to run the ball.

Not after they coolly dealt with a discomfiting setting in which they flew up and back to Newark, N.J., at dawn and dusk and, at the same time, weren’t “even a little inconvenienced compared to what people are going through here,” as Mike Wallace gracefully referenced the region’s victims of Hurricane Sandy.

No, after all that, a three-game winning streak, a 5-3 record and a fresh strut to their step, it’s safe to say: The Steelers are back.

Or so I’d thought.

Running this concept from stall to stall in the locker room afterward, the reaction was remarkably — perhaps tellingly — similar.

“Back?” Casey Hampton said. “Naw, we’re gettin’ there, man. We know how dominant we can be, the type of team we can be. We know we’re playing OK, but we can be a lot better.”

“Getting there,” Chris Rainey said with a grin through the grimace of bruised ribs. “Just getting there.”

The most pointed response, predictably, came from Ryan Clark.

“No, we’re not back. We’re just playing football,” he said. “I think to be ‘back,’ we had to be considered gone, right? Only y’all considered us gone. I understood the type of men we had in here, the type of talent. But no, we’re not back. We just won a couple football games.”

Yeah, but … OK, you can’t fight City Hall on this stuff.

Still, let’s be real: It would be an injustice to describe this as anything less than the Steelers’ best showing since that thorough dissection of the Patriots last year at Heinz Field.

The athletes are right. This wasn’t dominant. It wasn’t the way the Steelers’ championship teams might have controlled the event front to finish. This team tips away passes. Those teams slammed the opposing quarterback 6 feet into the ground. It’s not the same feel.

And yet, this 2012 edition is taking on its own identity:

It’s dynamic.

It’s deep.

And it’s damned tough.

You see the dynamic every week with all the breakaway receivers, and you’re seeing it now in the return game. Once Emmanuel Sanders, Wallace and Rainey sprung free, the Giants had no answers.

“We’ve got a lot of guys who can bust it open,” Jerricho Cotchery said. “Eventually, we did.”

You see the depth where few would have expected.

The same Keenan Lewis who went without a solitary pass defensed in the first three games delivered three of those Sunday in the first quarter alone to keep the great Eli Manning from going all guns blazing.

The same running game that had been stuck at a historic crawl now makes it impossible to tell who’s No. 1, with Rashard Mendenhall, Jonathan Dwyer and Isaac Redman leapfrogging each other week after week.

Ask me, and Redman’s bulldozing 147 yards should make him No. 1.

Ask me next week, and I’ll probably answer differently.

And not enough praise can be heaped on an offensive line that’s running downhill with so much gravity they could be dubbed Newton’s Line. Give credit to the backs, but just remember that the line is the constant.

Loved this line from rookie tackle Mike Adams, who was burned early but recovered nicely: “To have a number of backs rushing well behind us, it’s something we take a lot of pride in.”

The toughness is my favorite facet, though.

Stop and think to how many times Sunday this team experienced something so deflating, so dispiriting you thought that was it.

The phantom pass interference call on Lewis?

“Didn’t touch the guy,” he said.

The flag on Clark for hitting the Giants’ Victor Cruz “in the head,” according to anatomically challenged referee Bill Leavy, who clearly saw Cruz’s head down where his ribs should be?

“I tried to obey the rules,” Clark said.

The weird — though at least debatable — ruling that Ben Roethlisberger fumbled when a) his arm moved forward b) the ball was still touching his hand and c) the ball was actually thrown forward?

“I had complete control,” Roethlisberger said.

Those officiating mistakes essentially handed New York 14 points.

And what about Tomlin’s bizarre, boneheaded call for Shaun Suisham to take that circus-like flip on a fake field goal rather than going for a fourth-and-1 with, you know, his franchise quarterback?

“They overcome bad coaching sometimes,” the coach said of his players. “That’s on me.”

A team made of lesser stuff crumbles after just one of those events, never mind all of the above plus the 6-2 defending champs competing in an emotional cauldron. The Giants made no secret that they wished to play hero for a day, coach Tom Coughlin calling this “as disappointing a loss as we’ve had around here in a long time” mostly for that reason.

But these Steelers don’t crumble. And they didn’t.

Are they back?

Maybe not all the way, but …

“We’re getting better,” Heath Miller said. “And if that means we’re getting back to Steelers football, we’ll take it.”

http://triblive.com/sports/2891495-74/steelers-getting-football-giants-team-sunday-ball-clark-lot-mike#ixzz2BUzXZQDa

OX1947
11-06-2012, 09:23 PM
Steelers will officially be back when they whip the Ratbirds twice in 3 weeks and lock the division.

grward
11-07-2012, 04:08 PM
Simms called out a ref?
When?
I guess I missed that one.

Phil Simms has spent the better part of his broadcasting career playing it safe and acting as a tool for the League and wouldn't step in to a controversy even with Goodell's permission, so I'd love to know what he said!

He was silent on the PI call that helped set up the Giants' first score. He even said that he wasn't going to "get into" whether or not it was a good call.

WTF?

If you don't address THAT, then what was there to talk about?
That call sucked and everyone who saw it knew that!

I thought the same thing. It sounded more like Simms was covering for the Refs. During the NFL Replay I listened closer and Simms kept saying things like 'Game speed" and "that's a tough call to make" and a few other comments that made it sound like he was okay with the calls even if they were questionable. I guess it's all in your own perception.

sluggermatt15
11-10-2012, 10:11 AM
YES, I give Simms a lot of credit for saying what he did about the PI call on Lewis, the "hit to the head" on Clark, the "tuck rule" non call and the no call on the "block in the back" on the return.

Make no mistake...Phil Simms is a NYG hall of fame QB and a professional broadcaster trying to point out bad calls while not insulting the NFL and its officials that so many fans insisted that the NFL open its wallets for.

Simms called that game objectively, whereas Dan Fouts sounded like a Raiders homer when the Steelers played the Raiders.

Great job Phil Simms :hatsoff:

Agree. Simms has the right to voice his opinion. And he was clearly correct. The PI calls were ridiculous. It was nice to see a non-Steelers broadcaster not hate on them for once. Usually, Simms and Nantz are totally against Pittsburgh in the way they call Steelers games, even though they are supposed to act neutral.

FrancoLambert
11-10-2012, 05:22 PM
Most of the calls were bogus.
I was at the game. Steeler Nation was VERY WELL represented and very vocal supporting the Black and Gold. The sight of so many Terrible towels waving at an away game was awesome.
Giant fans are very friendly and knowledable.
Nearby fans getting the Giants radio broadcast were saying even the Giant annoiuncers were questioning the calls, especially Ben's fumble.
There definitely was a "Sandy Effect" on the officiating.