Steelers Fever Forums

Steelers Fever Forums (http://forums.steelersfever.com/index.php)
-   Pittsburgh Steelers (http://forums.steelersfever.com/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   To Challenge or not To challenge (http://forums.steelersfever.com/showthread.php?t=19967)

OneForTheToe 09-23-2007 05:36 PM

To Challenge or not To challenge
 
Probably the only bit of controversy that will be seen in the Burgh this week. Should Tomlin have challenged the incomplete pass to the Niner's TE in the second half? One thing is for sure, the Ref's seem to have blown the play.

To me the question comes down to the rules of replay in the NFL. When the ref goes into the replay booth is he restricted by the specific issue at challenge, or can he make a determination based on another issue as long as it is still a reviewable issue? Does anyone know? If the Ref is restricted by the issue challenged, then maybe Tomlin should have challenged. However, if they are not restricted then it would have been useless for Tomlin to challenge the play because the Ref would have already considered all issues regarding that particular play.

Pheww ... did that make any sence?:dang::wave:

Livinginthe past 09-23-2007 05:51 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by OneForTheToe (Post 298626)
Probably the only bit of controversy that will be seen in the Burgh this week. Should Tomlin have challenged the incomplete pass to the Niner's TE in the second half? One thing is for sure, the Ref's seem to have blown the play.

To me the question comes down to the rules of replay in the NFL. When the ref goes into the replay booth is he restricted by the specific issue at challenge, or can he make a determination based on another issue as long as it is still a reviewable issue? Does anyone know? If the Ref is restricted by the issue challenged, then maybe Tomlin should have challenged. However, if they are not restricted then it would have been useless for Tomlin to challenge the play because the Ref would have already considered all issues regarding that particular play.

Pheww ... did that make any sence?:dang::wave:

I did happen to see that play.

First up, I think the ball did hit the ground - otherwise I can't see how the ball gained so much 'spring' from the inside of the arm.

As far as challenges go - im pretty sure you only challenge a certain element of the play.

So yes, I think Tomlin could have challenged the fact that the ball hit the ground, though I think it would have been close to impossible to say with any certainty that it didn't - which is what is required to over turn the call.

I happen to think the receiver was actually down - but that rule is open to interpretation it could go either way depending on the ref's mood.

As it happened a 50 yd FG is a (literal) long shot at Heinz - I thought Tomlin made the right call...or non-call.

Haiku_Dirtt 09-23-2007 06:21 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Livinginthe past (Post 298627)
I did happen to see that play.

First up, I think the ball did hit the ground - otherwise I can't see how the ball gained so much 'spring' from the inside of the arm.

As far as challenges go - im pretty sure you only challenge a certain element of the play.

So yes, I think Tomlin could have challenged the fact that the ball hit the ground, though I think it would have been close to impossible to say with any certainty that it didn't - which is what is required to over turn the call.

I happen to think the receiver was actually down - but that rule is open to interpretation it could go either way depending on the ref's mood.

As it happened a 50 yd FG is a (literal) long shot at Heinz - I thought Tomlin made the right call...or non-call.


It was 49 yards -not 50. Your right about the "long shot at Heinz." I may be wrong but no Steeler has kicked one 50 or longer at Heinz. That kick by Reed today would have been good from 60 yards out.

It's the little things and the big things that are going right this season. I'm trying to think what is different this season :scratchchin:

tony hipchest 09-23-2007 06:24 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Livinginthe past (Post 298627)
I did happen to see that play.

First up, I think the ball did hit the ground - otherwise I can't see how the ball gained so much 'spring' from the inside of the arm.

As far as challenges go - im pretty sure you only challenge a certain element of the play.

So yes, I think Tomlin could have challenged the fact that the ball hit the ground, though I think it would have been close to impossible to say with any certainty that it didn't - which is what is required to over turn the call.

I happen to think the receiver was actually down - but that rule is open to interpretation it could go either way depending on the ref's mood.

As it happened a 50 yd FG is a (literal) long shot at Heinz - I thought Tomlin made the right call...or non-call.

i guarantee that there will be plenty said about this next week by those who are desperately trying to find a chink in tomlins coaching armor.

the call was f--- up from the beginning. a catch is a catch is a catch. the ball was caught, the ground cannot cause a fumble, and by all means it shouldve been ruled a reception (this is my biggest pet peve in football).

the steelers actually lucked out with a shitty ruling.

for all those who are gonna question tomlins coaching decision: why would he throw a flag and review a play that the refs had just reviewed? they looked at the play, they made their decision. is a second challenge really gonna change what they saw and ruled on?

good job by tomlin not throwing an irrational challenge flag. that is why he is coach and the fans are fans. if any media questions his decision, they are retarded.

fwiw, those are the plays tomlin thrives on to see how his team responds to adversity. the defense responded just like last week when tomlin was questionned for not throwing a flag on a long kick off return.

again, any inevitible article questionning tomlins lack of challenges should be immediately discredtited.

choose youre battles wisely and pick the ones you know you can win.

Haiku_Dirtt 09-23-2007 06:58 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
[QUOTE=tony hipchest;298637 why would he throw a flag and review a play that the refs had just reviewed? they looked at the play, they made their decision. is a second challenge really gonna change what they saw and ruled on?[/QUOTE]

That actually happened in a Pac-10 game USC vs. I think Oregon. Carroll threw the flag and won the ruling only to have Belotti throw the flag to have the call re-reversed :dang:.

If someone is looking for a Tomlin mistake so far should use Windex on the mirror before they next look into it.

Dude has a layer of teflon thicker than perhaps even Reagan IMHO.

moedap 09-23-2007 06:59 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
I agree with what Tony said!

fansince'76 09-23-2007 07:01 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
Bottom line: we won by 21. :coffee:

Steeler in Carolina 09-23-2007 07:38 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
I also think the play was a catch and runner was down, however it worked well for me because I have Nedney on my fantasy team.

Tim 09-23-2007 07:51 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
The ground can't cause a fumble, that much is true, but it's also true that you have to establish that you have possession for it to be ruled a catch.

The instant he had the ball he got crushed and upended, when he came down the ball came out. I'm not sure how he could have had possession of the ball.

tony hipchest 09-23-2007 08:17 PM

Re: To Challenge or not To challenge
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim (Post 298679)
The ground can't cause a fumble, that much is true, but it's also true that you have to establish that you have possession for it to be ruled a catch.

The instant he had the ball he got crushed and upended, when he came down the ball came out. I'm not sure how he could have had possession of the ball.

he had 2 feet down before he was flipped.... = a catch (possession).

today was another fine example of the refs not being perfect.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:51 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Shoutbox provided by vBShout v6.2.1 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.0.8 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2014 DragonByte Technologies Ltd. Runs best on HiVelocity Hosting.
Navbar with Avatar by Motorradforum