Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

This is espn insider only ranking but I'll give the listing of Steelers players they think that are in the Top 200

8. Big Ben
13. James Harrison
18. Troy Polamalu
46. Lawrence Timmons
54. Mike Wallace
59. Lamarr Woodley
102 Rashard Mendenhall
123 Casey Hampton
128 Maurice Pouncey
154 James Farrior
165 Ike Taylor
180 Aaron Smith
192 Heath Miller
196 Hines Ward


its an interesting list and much better than the joke Top 100 NFL Network one. :tt04:

http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/story...layer-rankings

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

Definetly much better, especially with Ben. 8th isn't bad, although the QB is the most important position and since he's easily top 5 in the QB's, I don't see how he could be lower then 5 on any list. Either way, not bad. That just shows you what a poor bias joke the 100 list was, one of the top 5 QB's was 41st in the league!!!!

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

Yea, I can't stand watching NFL Network! So bias, They love their Eaggles now with all their free agents and being a so called "dream team" and of course the colts/saints/patriots because of Brady, Manning, and Brees oh and now Green Bay with Rodgers.:puke:

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

Revis was ranked #3...

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

Polamalu and Harrison should be swapped, but other than that I'd agree

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

PLEASE take Peyton Manning out of the top 10! No way he is still that hi! :banging:

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

rankings are skewed imo. players should be ranked by how much of an impact they make toward the team winning games. After all, what separates the good from the bad is winning right?

With that said, I believe Ben should be top 5. definitely ahead of revis. how many times did revis take the game on his shoulders and win it for the jets?

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

I can tell without even looking at the rest of the list, just from the order the Steelers are in, that this is a much better list than NFLN's

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

Every single Steeler defender not named Gay or McFadden should be in the top 100 - period. Please tell me where they put Phillip Rivers - better not be ahead of Ben. That ticks me off more than anything.

Re: Scouts Inc Top 200 NFL players (14 steelers on list)
 

where would you suggest he goes? if he doesnt play then go 4-12 if they are lucky