Steelers Fever Forums

Steelers Fever Forums (
-   ** The War Room 2012 ** (
-   -   Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0 (

devin7558 03-25-2012 09:23 PM

Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
Here is my mock draft for the Steelers based on positional need, Steeler and NFL trends both in the draft and system wise, as well as some cap smart selections. WARNING!!!!: this is a truly lengthy read.

Round #1 (24) OT Jonathan Martin Stanford
NFL comparison: Eugene Monroe Jacksonville Jaguars

His stock is lower than a month or two ago and he is ripe to fall in this draft. Need some proof?

He is not a likely top 10 pick. That puts him 14 spots away from us. There are at least 4-5 offensive lineman in this draft ranked higher than him and playmakers and overall difference makers are thin in this draft. Borderline playoff teams (picks 13-20) will look to add difference makers at the skill positions. In that span the Bengals select twice and the Browns have an additional pick. They both need skill position players more than a tackle. "Project" type selections like Dontari Poe will be selected ahead of Martin and more than that the only team picking ahead of us with a truly glaring need at OT is Detroit. Though they will be in the hunt for O-line help they really need to fix their secondary and can fare with what they have on the o-line in light of Stafford pumping out such nasty #'s last season. CB's should fall in this draft and I fully expect Detroit to look there. Also look for teams who have already picked to trade into the 20's to select a QB like Ryan Tannehill or Brandon Weeden.

Now onto an analysis of Jonathan Martin. He is not a flashy or high profile pick and fits the mold of a typical late first round Steeler selection. He is simply productive and solid at everything he does. At 6'5" 312 and with long arms he has the physical tools to compete for a starting spot at either tackle position. He played against good competition and kept QB Andrew Luck clean a lot more often than not. His experience and time in a true pro style offense that ran the ball well figures into the Steelers plans. He is an underrate run blocker who plays with good leverage. He is an average athlete who will work hard and has the brains to excel. Quick feet and good slide and mirror abilities give him the best chance to protect the left side against typical speed rushers. He can provide some nice training camp competition at LT for Marcus Gilbert wherein the loser moves to the RT spot and Willie Colon can kick inside to his natural position at RT. A pick like this fixes the offensive line in one fell swoop. If this scenario happens Martin represents the bet player available as well as the value and need rarely seen in a first round selection for any team.

Expect this to be the selection if Martin falls to 24 or within reach of a logical trade for Colbert and Tomlin.

Round #2 (57) ILB Mychal Kendricks California
NFL Comparison: Navarro Bowman San Francisco 49ers

The Steeler defense need a starting ILB from this draft and it is a thin group! With OL getting the attention in the first I expect this to be the pick in the second. Enter: Mychal Kendricks. He is a bit undersized in height at 5'11 240 but is strong and physical in the box and played all 52 games of his college career. He played the ILB in a true 3-4 at Cal. He worked out well at the draft and ran an awesome 40 (though i dont honestly care about 40 times). I put on the game tape and I see a Harrison type playmaker but at ILB instead. He is instinctive and explosive and really wrangles ball carriers like nothing! He is stout and strong and plays with a blue collar attitude which will win over coaches. He is low key, plays smart, and avoids stupid penalties. Youtube this kid's highlight reel if you dont believe meI He oooozes STEELER. He can cover slot WR's and pass catching TE's and step up and fill gaps to stop the run when needed. He's a solid wrap up tackler and a big hitter when given the oppurtunity and would easily beat out both Foote and Sylvester if given the chance. I think he is the most complete ILB in this years draft and a steal if he can be had with our second round selection. He also opens up the possibility of cutting Foote to save cap space should that be needed. At worst he is a year away, he adds competition to help push Sylvester and is the quality depth player you look for who can learn while playing special teams.

Round #3 (89) NT Josh Chapman Alabama
NFL Comparison: Sione Pouha NY Jets

This is the best time in the draft to ensure that the steelers fill a need with a quality prospect. They can ride Hampton for one last campaign and groom this zero technique to take over in 2013. He is squarely built at about 6'1 320 and plays like it! He wins the leverage battle and draws consistent double teams which is a must. He has the elite strength you look for in a true NT benching 610 at BAMA while squatting nearly 800lbs. He played through a torn Meniscus and ACL last season and was a cornerstone in that defense. For example, when Chapman left the lineup for only one game his defense was rung up by lowly Georgia Southern to the tune of 302 rushing yds. He was the building block for BAMA's 3-4, not Hightower, and he can be ours for the next 10 seasons. You have to select him here and not wait! It is not a reach.

Round #4 (121) TE Lardarious Green Lousiana-Lafayette
NFL Comparison: Ed Dickson Baltimoron Ravens

The Steelers need a young stud TE who can take that second spot now that Wesely Saunders is suspended for 4 games to start the 2012 season. Saunders will be lucky to make it out of training camp with a job. Green is receiving TE who is a limited blocker but that will not stop Colbert (who values TE's and knows his new Off. Coordinator does as well). Green is durable and catches the ball well down the seam and in the soft spots between zone defense. He is faster than timed and is tall and rangey at 6'6 and 238lbs. He can get stronger and add 10-15lbs at the NFL level without comprimising his speed. He is a toy at this point but if the Steelers lose Mike Wallace (or at best can't sign him long term) this gives the offense a piece to throw at and mitigate the lost production from losing Wallace. And lets face it, the scouts and coaches are looking for these top flight pass catching TE prospects they once missed on in guys like Rob Gronkowski, Aaron Hernandez and Jimmy Graham. His ceiling is not as high as those guys but he can be a solid 40 catch 500-600 yd TE who adds size and threat inside the redzone. The Steelers need that. I fully expect Colbert to look his way in this draft.

Round #5 (153) OG Lucas Nix Pittsburgh
NFL Comparison: Richie Incognito Miami Dolphins

Though the Steelers rarely select local talent I feel confident that they will place Lucas Nix pretty high on their draft board. He's a quality kid who can help in the rushing attack and develop his pass blocking abilities in the mean time. He is coachable, has the size (6'5" 315) and mean streak NFL scouts like and will provide depth at a spot they need it at. He is a value here and they simply need more big bodies to compete along the OL in training camp. He has the look of a potential future starter and may need time but the desire and talent is there. With proper coaching he could be a potential LG who can be effective in the pulling and trapping game for a lunch pail offense that I expect to see Todd Haley use more than BA did in the past.

Round #6 (185) FS Aaron Henry Wisconsin
NFL Comparison: Ryan Clark Pittsburgh Steelers

With Ryan Clark and Troy Polamalu both on the wrong side of 30 the Steelers need to look for some players than can be groomed to play if they go down with injury. Though both our starters play at a very high level and can probably stay there the next season or 2, the organization likes to think ahead and reload rather than rebuild. Henry gives them a piece to accomplish that. He has good cover skills and has played CB as well before moving to safety at Wisconsin.He is an above average tackler racking up 58 in 13 games last season will picking off 2 balls and defending 7 passes. Doesnt play the ball as much as youd like and has suspect hands. Sounds like a Steelers DB to me! He will certainly be undervalued coming off a minor knee surgery. He could be a steal if he falls to us here.

Round #7 (217) K Blair Walsh Georgia
NFL Comparison: Rian Lindell

Do you trust Suisham? I don't. He needs to be replaced with a cheap talent who can make kicks. Walsh fits that prototype and has a big leg. He went 20/23 last season kicking 8 FG's from 40+ and a long of 53 yds. He will have some rough spots if you defer to him in his rookie season but has the talent to succeed. He could also be used as a kickoff specialist as he averaged 65.9 yds per kickoff with 12 touchbacks last season. Not a bad piece to push Suisham in camp and eventually replace him. You could do worse with your 7th round selection.

A big thank you to all who took the time to read through this massive write up! I love the NFL draft and the Steelers and would be excited to see the draft unfold like this for us. Comments, flames, and criticism are encouraged! three, two, one.....GO!!!!

Bayz101 03-26-2012 12:33 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
I like the mock! Good work!

MasterOfPuppets 03-26-2012 12:48 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
the ONLY way the steelers would draft a tackle that high is if they planned to move colon to guard.

19ward86 03-26-2012 12:52 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
I dont see a tackle being taken. I see a G, NT, CB, or ILB...i dont see much chance of an early o-line pick just because thats how the Steelers roll. Draft quality recievers and have no Oline...compared to the Patriots who draft quality Oline and pick up scrub recievers (welker was a scrub in miami)

pete74 03-26-2012 04:02 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
i agree with you, if a good Tackle is there we will take him. im thinking Adams from Ohio State though. everyone can say who the steelers wont or will draft but nobody knows. we take BPA and thats it. i didnt see anyone who thought we would draft Heyward last season. its nothing more then a guess

El-Gonzo Jackson 03-26-2012 08:02 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0

Originally Posted by MasterOfPuppets (Post 1004381)
the ONLY way the steelers would draft a tackle that high is if they planned to move colon to guard.

We don't often expect rookies to start. If Martin is there he is BPA. He would likely solve our LT position for a long time, but wouldn't likely start there for a year or two.

devin7558 03-26-2012 10:30 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
For as much as we always need offensive lineman the steelers havent been hesitant to select them early in the past 2 drafts. they did select pouncey with a 1st rounder and the next season followed it up with gilbert so that may be the lone reason they will avoid taking a guy like martin or adams with this years 1st rounder.

im not high on mike adams but i think hightower, poe and glenn will all be off the board at 24. I think martin makes sense at that point. he can sit and develop for a season or push for a starting spot and kick colon inside to his natural position. its a BPA pick. if none of these players are there at 24 i think they should explore trade options to move back for additional 2nd and 3rd round picks.

Kingmagyar 03-26-2012 11:07 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
Your first 3 rounds would be great. I mean Martin would be a steal at 24 considering he could go as high as 13. Kendricks seems to be a player that can cover the pass very well going with the trend of today's NFL. Chapman is a solid guy to build up for the NT of the future. Things could go a lot worse then that for the Steelers. So very good first 3 round mock. DB late is a good choice as well.

But, yet another mock without a Wide Receiver taken, when it is a great draft class for Wide Receivers and we are low in WR depth with only 3 signed one being Wallace a RFA and the other 2 about to be RFAs.

Colbert values TEs but they better be able to block. The whole offense if based on that. I don't see the Steelers drafting a TE who weighs 238 lbs and can not block. I don't think it would happen. They need a guy like that for red zone but why would you take him when you can get a receiver of almost the same height a little less weight but runs much faster in the 4.4 range? A 4th rounder doesn't have to be a starter though so they could take him and use him as a novelty in the red zone but I'd take a WR.

-as you can tell I am hung up on the Steelers taking a WR in this year's draft. It's become my personal crusade.

And one last thought. I do believe it is a great first 3 rounds for Guards. And this team needs one probably more then any position on this team. We would need a better guard then Nix. I don't know where you would draft him but we need one.

Fire Arians 03-26-2012 11:56 AM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
kendricks is an interesting pick. I think we're gonna go after him if we can't land hightower with the 24th pick.

i prefer glenn in rd 1, we need guard more than anything right now

devin7558 03-26-2012 01:11 PM

Re: Steelers 2012 Mock Draft vers 1.0
awesome suggestions...its food for thought!

I agree guard is the HUGE need but i only see two guards worth a pick @ 24 and thats DeCastro and Glenn. I think both will be gone when we pick as well as Hightower and Poe. Any others at that point are reachesIMO.

WR is a need but only for depth. the top 3 are set for at least this season.
moving forward they do need more there so maybe they do look for a WR but i dont think any in rounds 2-3 are worth more than the NT or ILB of the future.

admittedly i did choose a few athletes i personally like so maybe taking some of that out of this mock would yield a more realistic forecast. the steelers are a hard team to mock draft for!

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:57 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Shoutbox provided by vBShout v6.2.1 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2015 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.0.8 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2015 DragonByte Technologies Ltd. Runs best on HiVelocity Hosting.
Navbar with Avatar by Motorradforum