For the money I'd have to go with Mendy. He has been running plays designed to fail, with no lead blocker or worse than no blocker, (Scarey Davis, and David Whiff Johnson). Jones-Drew sure has gashed us more than his share though, and he is a great runner. I have to agree that Mendenhall hasn't had the chance to show us what he has yet, and I hope he heals enough to do so. Having him and Redmen healthy and utilized will be great, especially if Ben can get with the disciplined approach, and figure out when the right time to extend the plays is. We could have a scary good offense, rather than just the scary one we have had.