Why even compare the two?
You can talk about stats all you want - the guy is good as gone - regardless if you like or hate him.
AB played the game (both on and off the field) to the best of his abilities, and therefore, earned the contract. When the guys number is called - he executes in critical situations. People would be singing a different tune if the guy was having a bad season, but was "acting like a Steeler." He's not. Bye, bye Mikey