01-16-2013, 07:37 PM
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Toronto Canada
Member Number: 19128
Thanked 105 Times in 72 Posts
Re: The prospect of just keeping mendenhall
Originally Posted by Riddle_Of_Steel
Really? They had one or two better games this year, but it was understood that Mendy returned in 12 months from an injury that calls for an 18 month recovery.
Either way, it seems we are willing to give Ben a pass for being hurt, but not Mendenhall.
Over the course of their careers:
864 carries, 3549 yards (avg 4.1 ypc), avg 62.3 yards per game
181 carries, 774 yards (avg 4.3 ypc), avg 36.9 yards per game
272 carries, 1136 yards (avg 4.2 ypc), avg 24.2 yards per game
How have Redman and Dwyuer performed better than Mendenhall? They had slightly better yards per carry, but they played in limited roles. The average yards per game tells all. A franchise RB needs to be counted on to provide more than 35 yards per game.
They have yet to manage a 1000-yard season, which Mendy has done for us in a pass-happy scheme with no Oline to speak of, SEVERAL TIMES.
Also, would be nice if they displayed the ability to carry the rock for 300+ times per season. Neither Dwyer nor Redman manged to string together more than 2 games at a time this year.
THIS would be a great role for Redman. Dwyer can be the backup/powerback in someone else's offense.
Becauise he is the only one who has shown the franchise RB pedigree we need.
How was he a blown #1 pick? Multiple 1000-yard seasons in bonehead Arians' scheme behind patchwork offensive lines? How did Redman and Dwyer do behind a much improved Oline this year, in comparison to Mendenhall? Have either of these other two bozos shown they can stay healthy for an entire season while getting only a portion of the carries? Do either Redman or Dwyer have any open-field ability (well, Redman does), or ability to cut a long one around the edges?
I really don't know what some of you are looking at.
Totally agree. I have no idea what you guys are seeing or watching. Redman and dwyer would be 2nd or 3rd stringers on any other team but here in Pitttsburgh u guys see these guys as the next Franco!! Please!! When comparing the 3; there is no comparison. If we can bring Mendy back at a good price and Tomlin stops his pissing war with him; they can fill other needs on the roster as there are MANY!!