Originally Posted by cowherpower
If starting a franchise today and basing decision on age and upside alone, not thinking about past performance. Strictly who would I want for the next 5-7 years as franchise QB and considering QB position is evolving into a more athletic type
Eli (has two rings and came up bigger than Ben in SB)
Peyton (only because he is elite now but unlikely to play 5 years otherwise higher)
In 5-7 years, Brady will be 41-43, Manning 42-44, Brees 39-41.
Your list sucks.