Of course he's great - he won a Super Bowl!
I'm so tired of reading that line on these forums, but thankfully, nearly always someone takes the time to squash the silly logic. But why should we waste the time? We can just refer them to this thread!
I'll start it off with two examples that should be noncontroversial.
Punter - Mitch Berger
OC - Bruce Arians
Go go go!!!