Re: I'd like opinions on my predicament.....
I never value kickers high. But since its a keeper league I don't know if the fellow owners in your league are keeping the top kickers. But I don't know if I would keep a kicker. I'm with you about Duckett. He will get the goal line carries and if your in a league thats mainly a TD league then that would wise.
The thing with Fred Taylor he has the talent to be very good back. But can never stay healthy.