Re: If you were starting the Steelers from scratch and could keep only ONE player...
It has to be Troy.
With Willie runningback is a position that's too easy to fill, same with Mendy.
Most of the list is honestly too old for me to want to start a franchise around.
And guys like Santonio and Woodley just aren't there yet in my opinion, daaang close but not to that 'franchise' level in my opinion.
Troy is fairly young, not too longi n the tooth and plays in a very impactful way - perfect to build a defense around.