Originally Posted by Nadroj 20
He is a good football player and i dont have a problem with Tebow, but he didnt have a heisman year and if he wins i'll have a tough time not beleiving this as well.
I have HUGE problems with Timmy winning which I have expressed in many places on the board. Putting ALL of that aside, he simply did not have a Heisman year, IMO
I agree with Revs that McElroy had an absolutely outstanding game against the Gators. I find it interesting that he has never lost a game that he started as QB since 8th grade...
In my opinion he is a much more complete QB than Tebow (who is good, but overrated)
As for Ingram...correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't he a sophomore
? I don't know how many juniors have won the Heisman, but I don't think it should be a consideration at all. If a player is performing up to the standards of the award (Most Outstanding Football Player), he should get it.
Here are some more facts about the Heisman
My vote goes to Ingram
(he's gonna be a beast when he gets to the big leagues if
he stays healthy and if
he doesn't pull a Ricky Williams)