Titan / Steeler player swap

[Acerinox]

OK wutchy listen up because this is important.

Troy and Ben are what we call "generational" talents. They're the kind of players that come along once in a generation. There has never been a more disruptive, intelligent or influential DB than Polamalu. He brings Elite with him - not just as an individual - but to the team he plays on. And Ben is probably the most clutch QB in history. More than that - he is another team player. Not a gaudy stats passer, but someone who will get the dirty job done for his team.

You cannot replace these people, k? There are no "equivalents" or "alternatives" for them out there. It doesn't matter that they're getting old. You can't replace them. It's as simple as that. So you just ride them and make sure they never leave until they get too old to play any more. And then you sigh, and say "wasn't it great when we used to watch Ben and Troy".

[El Nino]

Originally Posted by wutchy

I'd take Johnson or Mark Ingram. is that a bad thing? Can i have that opinion and preference?

of course i respect most opinions but i honestly think you're joking. i mean you can't be serious right? lol

CJ over mendenhall is debatable, theres no denying that CJ is extremely talented. but vince over ben? you can't be serious

[wutchy]

Originally Posted by Wallace108

Fine, I'll play along ...

Why I wouldn't trade Ben for Vince Young:
Ben is a 2-time (soon to be 3-time) Super Bowl champion. Vince Young sucks.

Debate over.

And two-time super bowl champ Ben sucks in super bowls and most sundays. You need to finish drives and put more than 10 points on the board. The defense wins games week after week, not Ben.

[MattsMe]

Originally Posted by wutchy

So you'd prefer Mendy over Chris Johnson and Mark Ingram?
I'd take Julio Jones or Prince Amukumara if Ingram is gone. Ingram could be a third down back or a return man extroidanaire.

I'm sorry, I already used up my daily allotment of responses to ridiculous posts for the day.

Please check back tomorrow.

[PhantomJB93]

I lol'd

[wutchy]

Originally Posted by El Nino

and lets trade wallace for finnegan!

Who said that , troll?

[El Nino]

Originally Posted by wutchy

Who said that , troll?

what, i can't have an opinion?

[Buddha Bus]

Originally Posted by wutchy

Vince could win in Pittsburgh because he could do anything Ben could do.

Yeah except, shake off defenders, win, show poise, be able to work through adversity gracefully, win, work well behind a shaky O-line, win, come through in the clutch over and over, win, lead his team to multiple Super Bowls, have his teammates faith and did I say WIN?

Originally Posted by wutchy

Ben doesn't have numbers.

How about these numbers:

2 Super Bowl rings (with a possible 3rd on the way) to... wait for it... 0!!!!!

[Sixburgher]

Originally Posted by The Curtain's Crusader

Guys:

He REALLY IS serious. Maybe we should take him seriously. Or maybe just go all in and do a complete team trade. Three-peat here we come.

Consider the source. This is the same dope that swore Santonio Holmes would light us up and score at LEAST 2 touchdowns in the AFC Championship Game.

Once again, crack kills.

[Neil-Still-Rules-14]

Originally Posted by wutchy

And two-time super bowl champ Ben sucks in super bowls and most sundays. You need to finish drives and put more than 10 points on the board. The defense wins games week after week, not Ben.

I'm not even going to take the time out of my day to point out all of the flaws in this concept.