Who's ticketed for Canton?

[msafford]

Originally Posted by RoethlisBURGHer

Okay you have guys who have not signed a contract to even play in the NFL yet on a list of guys who will be "Cantonized",you have guys who didn't even start an entire season last year in thier rookie years...but Ben is an "odd man out"?

He broke every rookie record out there for good performance.Then he went on to become the youngest QB to ever win a Super Bowl in his second year.His third year he has some injury problems and all of a sudden he never was a good QB to begin with?

He got us to that Super Bowl by coming back against Cinci,creating a lead for us to sit and run on against Indy and Denver,and without some big plays from him we don't win the Super Bowl.

Then again,this is ESPIN.

Yeah but he was the product of the system, right? It wasn't because of his actual ability!

[Jman]

I think it is well summed in saying, "It's ESPN." Seriously, this network has become horrible.

[fansince'76]

ESPN. 'Nuff said.

[SteelCityMan786]

Originally Posted by Jman

I think it is well summed in saying, "It's ESPN." Seriously, this network has become horrible.

I take CBS, FSN, FOX, etc. over them unless otherwise noted for Football. Well, NFL at least.

[xXTheSteelKingsXx]

Wow Fred Taylor not even mentioned as on the bubble and he's only 500 some yards from 10,000!

[rog]

If I never seen Who's Now I would say this is the dumbest list I have ever seen but since I have unfortunatly seen Who's Now I would say it's just tied for the dumbest list I have ever seen. What is the point of trying to figure out or predict who will make it to the Hall of Fame. After all the Hall of Fame is a reward for hard work, sacrafice, determination, and amazing talent. Big Ben lead his team to a 15 and 1 record and an AFC championchip game his rookie year then to a Super Bowl victory. I still (even bbing the Steeler fan I am) would never say he is going to be a Hall of Famer yet it is just to soon. With that being said having Vince Young, Matt Lienert, Calvin Johnson and A.J. Hawk on this list is just ridiculous. I wonder what guys like L.C. or Art Monk feel about this kind of stuff because there are guys out there that have done the things through out their careers to get them into the Hall, and yet some of the ones that deserve this recognition may never get.

[Godfather]

Do you have to have a room-temperature IQ to work for ESPN?

If you're going to talk about rookies and second year players, at least pick the ones who had better seasons, like Joseph Addai and Marques Colston.