Byron Leftwich or Dixon

[tube517]

True. But at least Dixon could hand off to Mendy and not break his hand.

Originally Posted by JCPsteelers

The funny part is that Kordell was ten times better than Dixon yet fans here act like Dennis Dixon is some kind of potential Hall of Famer.. Did you see the same game that I did vs the Ravens where his throwing was god awful and other than one pass to Holmes (blown coverage/Foxworth couldn't cover my grandma) and his 30 yard run he did nothing in the game that was that impressive. He threw a great pass to a Ravens DE that cost us a playoff spot though..


Great trade by FO by getting Leftwich back in here.. We at least will have a competent QB since Dictator Goodell will suspend Big Ben for "allegations"

[steelerohio]

I picked Byron but I know the coaches will put in who's the better QB...

[El-Gonzo Jackson]

Originally Posted by HometownGal

Lefty - hands down.

I think Dixon is going to be damned good but that being said, I'd prefer Lefty to step in for Ben as he did a stellar job while he was here.

I agreee with this line of thought. Leftwich can manage the game and has won in this league. Dixon will be productive, but might not be as far along as we hope.

Plus, Dixon can then play WR since Bongtonio is gone.

[stlrtruck]

Although Goodell sucks, I voted for Dixon.

Give me youth if I can't have Ben!

[Indo]

Originally Posted by whatdoiknow

Hey Gal,,,Hands down...? How is that ? Lefty played against horrid teams when he was here, and only did good against a Washington team that sucked to. But that was his Home town. I mean Lefty was so good he couldn't beat out two rookies in Tampa . I like him. But no way should he just be GIVEN the starters job. He should be made to beat out Dixon in camp, and pre-season games.



Any other opinion then that is just plain ridiculous!

Why is it that EVERY opinion other than yours in every thread that you post in is "just plain ridiculous?"
You do realize that there are hundreds (if not thousands) of members of this board and ALL OF THEM probably have an opinion which is different from yours, don't you?

It would be nice if you would start showing some RESPECT to others...

[stlrtruck]

Originally Posted by whatdoiknow

Hey Gal,,,Hands down...? How is that ? Lefty played against horrid teams when he was here, and only did good against a Washington team that sucked to. But that was his Home town. I mean Lefty was so good he couldn't beat out two rookies in Tampa . I like him. But no way should he just be GIVEN the starters job. He should be made to beat out Dixon in camp, and pre-season games.



Any other opinion then that is just plain ridiculous!

Sorry man but Lefty wasn't the problem. The bucs coaches and owners were looking for a scapegoat and they found it in Lefty. The problem wasn't Lefty it was the entire offensive production, the play calling, etc. They didn't fair much better after Lefty was benched.