Why I wouldn't trade Ben for any other QB

[OX1947]

I would trade Ben for Kaep in a milli second.

[scottcurtis]

Originally Posted by harrison'samonster

welcome to the board. I disagree though, Ben was playing great before the injury. I'd like to see him play another season with the new offense and stay healthy; I think people will remember why he's such a good QB

you disagree ? Which team above would take Ben ?

[Terminator]

Originally Posted by OX1947

I would trade Ben for Kaep in a milli second.

Kaepernick is special. I see good things from him.

[Terminator]

I'd like to see Ben complete a season without actually getting hurt.

[harrison'samonster]

Originally Posted by scottcurtis

you disagree ? Which team above would take Ben ?

those other teams can't have him. He's a Steeler.

[scottcurtis]

Originally Posted by harrison'samonster

those other teams can't have him. He's a Steeler.

i dont think they would want him any way. ben has very little upside left. I cant see next season being any different. To me ben just doesnt have the desire to be "great" like alot of the other Qbs...such as Brady, Brees, Manning and Rodgers... just look how he comes to camp every year. totally out of shape compared to 98% of the other Qb's in the league, to be honest I cant think of a Qb thats in worse physical condition then BB. ben's arms look like jello campare to Colin K. and even the old man Payton.

[Fire Arians]

Originally Posted by Terminator

Kaepernick is special. I see good things from him.

he might be a 1 hit wonder like cam newton once teams get film on him. i'd much rather have someone like andrew luck

[Steelers>NFL]

Aaron Roger is the only QB that I would trade Big Ben for...

[maddog78]

Originally Posted by Fire Arians

he might be a 1 hit wonder like cam newton once teams get film on him. i'd much rather have someone like andrew luck

Or Greg Cook, Bill Kenney, Don Majkowski, Scott Mitchell, Erik Kramer, or any number of one hit wonders that teams overcommitted to and got burned by.

We know what we have in Ben for the next 3-5 years, I'd rather not trade away a chance at another Lombardi for a guy who's played a handful of games.

BTW, had Ben gone 16-28 with a pick and left his team at the 7-yard line at the end, he'd be getting crucified.

[steelfury02]

Originally Posted by maddog78

Or Greg Cook, Bill Kenney, Don Majkowski, Scott Mitchell, Erik Kramer, or any number of one hit wonders that teams overcommitted to and got burned by.

We know what we have in Ben for the next 3-5 years, I'd rather not trade away a chance at another Lombardi for a guy who's played a handful of games.

BTW, had Ben gone 16-28 with a pick and left his team at the 7-yard line at the end, he'd be getting crucified.

I'm willing to bet that if we get back to the SB, Ben will see all the missed opportunities that Kaep did not.

BTW - anyone notice Moss taking plenty of plays off and slowing up when traffic was coming? They really only played with 2 receivers all game - Crabtree and Davis. The damn fullback was the most effective by the 2nd half.