Big Ben vs Joe Flacco

[BlaZeQuietly]

if everyone wants to rank whose had the best careers I think Joe Montana and Roger Stauback and Bret Farve should be on the top ten list 2

[maddog78]

Originally Posted by BlaZeQuietly

I can understand that part, but that's my opinion. I was talking about this season, not their careers, What did Ben do this year?

What did Eli do this year to be the 5th ranked QB?

You sound like some FFL fanboy who only cares about yards.

[lloydwoodson]

Originally Posted by Steelers5895

Its hard to compare.

So lets try this:

Better Running back- FLACCO
Better Line- FLACCO
Better Wide Receivers- FLACCO
Better TE- BEN
Better Special Teams (field position)- FLACCO
Better Defense- PUSH

Ben needs another Hines Ward NOT another MIke Wallace. If Ben had Flacco's targets he would be putting up sick numbers.

Steelers #1 defense and Ravens #17 defense are a push?

Steelers wide receivers are MUCH better than the Ravens. The last Ravens WR to get 1000 yards was Derrick Mason in 09.

[Steelers5895]

Lets not get all wrapped up with kaepernick. Think Kordell Stewart. The NFl will adjust to this style of quarterback and they will not be as productive. the plus for him is he can throw too. i want to see more than 10 games. same with RG3, give me more than one year.

[BlaZeQuietly]

Originally Posted by maddog78

What did Eli do this year to be the 5th ranked QB?

You sound like some FFL fanboy who only cares about yards.

More than Ben did.

[maddog78]

Originally Posted by cowherpower

may be, but they all have a great chance at another ring in that time. More so than Ben. Your response sucks

In seven years, Manning and Brady will have a great chance at a ring?

[fer522]

Did you guys know that Rodgers (elite Qb) has won 1 playoff game in the las 2 seasons so flacco had a better year big fucking deal

[Steelers5895]

Originally Posted by lloydwoodson

Steelers #1 defense and Ravens #17 defense are a push?

Steelers wide receivers are MUCH better than the Ravens. The last Ravens WR to get 1000 yards was Derrick Mason in 09.

OMG will you guys get off the # 1 ranked defense. yes a push, they got sacks and turnovers and we got yards. PUSH

and yes, the Ravens WRS are much better:

Smith vs wallace- Smith is just as good a deep threat and has made some real tough catches. he is in year 2 and will be way better than wallace.

Boldin vs. Brown- Brown is more explosive BUT Boldin makes the tough catch and is a much better blocker. see te 4th and 27 play

Jones vs sanders- Jones is a big play guy, sanders is average and cant stay healthy.

just because you like our players because they are steelers doesnt make them the best ever. heck, why not say our receivers are better than the 99 rams trio.

[lloydwoodson]

Originally Posted by maddog78

What did Eli do this year to be the 5th ranked QB?

You sound like some FFL fanboy who only cares about yards.

Umm E Manning had an off year this year. Seems to me Blaze is judging Eli off body of work and you're the one overly focused on one season.

E Manning has 2 Superbowls so only Brady has more. E Manning has had a top 10 scoring offense every year for the last 5 years. Based on those 2 facts alone there is good cause for E Manning to be ranked highly even as high as 5th.

[BlaZeQuietly]

Don't get me wrong.. I'm sure Ben will have a great year next year and Id put him as # 4 or 5 again, this season though? no thanks, lets be realistic. I agree I may be jumping the gun with Kaepernick a little but If you watched him play this year he did an amazing job, hell he stole the starting job right out from under alex smith, must be doing something right.